Montreal Canadiens Beginning in the
1951–52 NHL season under coach
Dick Irvin, Harvey was named to the
All-Star team 11 consecutive times. He won the
James Norris Memorial Trophy in
1955, as the league's best defenceman, for the first of seven times. In an era when the defenceman's role did not include scoring points, Harvey used his skating speed and passing ability to become a factor in making the Canadiens a high-scoring team. He won the
Stanley Cup six times, all with Montreal. During the
1954 Finals, however, he scored a Cup-losing own-goal when he tried to block a shot by
Tony Leswick of the
Detroit Red Wings with his glove but instead tipped it past goalie
Gerry McNeil. McNeil, who struggled with the pressure of being an NHL goalie, quit hockey the following year. Between 1955 and 1962, Harvey won the James Norris Memorial Trophy as the NHL's top defenceman every year except
1959, when it went to his teammate
Tom Johnson. Prior to the
1960–61 season, the Canadiens players voted for Harvey to be their captain; he succeeded
Maurice Richard, who had served in that role for his last four years as a player. This was not welcomed by team management, who were not happy with Harvey's actions on and off the ice. Harvey again won the Norris Trophy in
1961–62, the first Ranger to do so. As coach, he tried to have the team play a similar style to what he had seen in Montreal, which helped the Rangers make the playoffs for the first time since 1958. Desiring to be closer to the players, which he felt was not possible as their coach, Harvey resigned as coach for the
1962–63 season, and was only convinced to remain with the Rangers when Patrick offered him a $30,000-per-year salary, reportedly the highest in NHL history to that point. Harvey's play remained at a high level: he led all NHL defencemen in scoring with 39 points, but was criticized for the team's lack of success. After recording two assists in 14 games during the
1963–64 season, Harvey continued to attract negative attention; rather than return to the minor leagues, he asked to be released from his contract.
Detroit Red Wings and St. Louis Blues In January 1967, Harvey was called up to play for the
Detroit Red Wings in a back-to-back series against the
Chicago Black Hawks. However he disappointed Red Wings management by showing up roughly overweight, and was largely ineffective in the two games, so was sent back to Pittsburgh for the remainder of the season. With the Hornets he won the
Calder Cup, the AHL championship, though the team disbanded after the season as the
Pittsburgh Penguins were due to start playing in the NHL for
1967–68. Harvey served as player-coach during his first season in New York, but was never entirely comfortable with this dual role. ==Post-playing career==