The album was released to generally positive reviews, with famed rock critic
Robert Christgau declaring the album "first-rate Byrds, a high recommendation." Johanna Schrier, writing in
The Village Voice, described the album as "smooth and strong like a blended whiskey", before suggesting that it was "Part kin to
Sweetheart of the Rodeo, part the acid offspring of
Notorious Byrd Brothers."
Disc magazine were particularly enthusiastic in their praise of the album, stating "[This is] their best album since perhaps
Younger Than Yesterday, perfectly illustrating the two completely disparate sides of the group: far-out electronic rock and hick, twangy country."
Dr. Byrds & Mr. Hyde was remastered at 20-
bit resolution as part of the
Columbia/Legacy Byrds series. It was reissued in an expanded form on March 25, 1997, with five
bonus tracks, including the
outtake "Stanley's Song". Although the producer of the Columbia/Legacy Byrds' series, Bob Irwin, has stated that only the first four Byrds' albums underwent any remixing, some fans of the band maintain that
Dr. Byrds & Mr. Hyde was also remixed, citing distinct differences between the 1997 reissue and the original album. Among the differences found on the reissue are a lessening of
reverb on many songs, the appearance of the spoken word "three" over the opening seconds of "This Wheel's on Fire", and a longer, unedited version of "Candy" appearing on the album for the first time. ==Track listing==