Formed in 1938, they operated with considerable success as first-class Juveniles during their first seven seasons, winning the Scottish Juvenile Cup twice in succession (1944–45 and 1945–46). In 1946, Dundonald turned Junior and soon became one of Fife's foremost clubs, winning the
league championship on three occasions in the 1950s. The Bell were crowned champions of the
East Region Central Division in 2006–07, and spent two seasons in the
East Premier League before being relegated. Season 2013–14 was a memorable one for the club as they gained promotion back to the East Premier League by finishing runners up in the East Region South League and also made the
Scottish Junior Cup quarter-finals for the first time in their history, losing to eventual winners
Hurlford United. Two years later Bluebell won promotion to the
East Superleague by finishing runners-up to
Jeanfield Swifts in the 2015–16 East Premier League. The club also reached the final of the East of Scotland Cup in the same season, losing to
Bo'ness United. Manager Craig Morrison left the club in the summer of 2016 to be replaced by Stevie Kay. In 2018, the club was part of a large movement of eastern junior clubs to the
East of Scotland Football League. ==Honours==