Eaten Back to Life is now considered by many to be an essential album in the death metal genre. John Weiderhorn of
Loudwire called the album "a raw and powerful collection of tunes that [has stood] the test of time." Adem Tepedelen of
Revolver wrote in 2006: "Cannibal Corpse became a gore-metal franchise with the release of their now-mandatory, splatter-flick-inspired debut." In 2020, Chris Krovatin of
Kerrang! wrote: "As far as death metal debuts go,
Eaten is an incredible record, full of wily guitars and Chris Barnes' patented hoarse growl, and for fans of that classic Scott Burns sound, this record can’t be beat. But in the long line-up of Cannibal Corpse’s discography, Eaten is more about how much promise you can hear on it than it is about death metal mastery." In 2023, Jon Weiderhorn of
Loudwire wrote: "At the time of its release,
Eaten Back to Life was one of the sickest, most demented death metal albums ever released. Of course, over the next five years Cannibal Corpse would release even faster, more disturbing songs and accompanying art work that would land them in the crosshairs of conservative, God-fearing Americans, politicians looking to gain points with scared parents and anyone unsettled by genuinely sick s--t. While it wasn’t the goal, the controversy helped Cannibal Corse sell more records and increase their following. Still, despite their influence Cannibal Corpse were too brutal to cross over into the mainstream." Weiderhorn also stated the belief that the album was "the perfect gateway to the underground" due to its thrash metal sound. In 2024, Joe DiVita of
Loudwire wrote: "One of the most enthralling things about the death metal’s pioneers and their debut records is hearing the genre itself being molded, wrought from thrash as each band put their stamp on what this new thing was becoming.
Eaten Back to Life helped change extreme music forever. Chris Barnes vividly graphic, brutal lyrics were and still are deranged, establishing a lyrical blueprint other acts have spent decades imitating." Some reviews were less positive. Leslie Mathew of
AllMusic gave the album an underwhelming retrospective review, criticizing the album's perceived lack of variety and "interesting
guitar work". The shirt was a long-sleeved
Eaten Back to Life Shirt, which had the band's original logo. The shirt was later revealed to have belonged to Barker himself. Barker responded to Barnes' comments, saying: "To speak on that, that's the lamest shit ever. Obviously my fiancée doesn't listen to Cannibal Corpse, but I do. I grew up loving them. For [someone] to mention that in a negative light — fucking lame, you know? She's wearing it because she's cold. She's not claiming she knows every song. But I do! I bought every album, and I learned how to play every album." Alex Webster was quoted as follows regarding the controversy: "I remember I’d see these classic shirts. You’ll see a
Motorhead shirt or
Ramones shirt or
Slayer logo shirt,
Iron Maiden shirt,
AC/DC shirt… Those kinds of things you’ll see in pop culture, not just in the music scene. [...] For us to start dipping into that a little bit... That was something I always kind of hoped would happen. I think anyone in a band [would want to] have that kind of growth in your career. To be able to really just be no one universally, in a way. It’s something you can kind of hope for, but you can’t really plan on it happening. So I think just by us having been around for a long time, it’s sort of gotten there over the years. Every now and then, there’ll be this weird pop culture kind of reference to us that you wouldn’t expect. And it can be it can be with merch or something like that. And to be fair, we’ve just been lucky in that way." ==Track listing==