Foy returned to Chicago in 1888 as the star comedian in variety shows and revues, initially for his own company. In 1889 he had a tremendous success as the star of the musical
Blue Beard, Jr. when it premiered at the
Grand Opera House, Chicago He then toured with that production nationally; including stops at Boston's
Tremont Theatre (1889) and
Broadway's
Niblo's Garden (1890). He also played the variety circuits for years in a series of song and dance acts. In 1896, Foy married his third wife, Madeline Morando, a dancer with his company.
Bryan (1896–1977);
Charley (1898–1984); Mary (1901–1987); Madeline (1903–1988);
Eddie Jr. (1905–1983); Richard (1905–1947); and Irving (1908–2003). Eddie Jr.'s son,
Eddie Foy III, was a casting director with
Columbia Pictures for over 40 years. Between 1901 and 1912, Foy played the leading comic roles in a series of musical comedies in New York City and on tour, including
The Strollers (1901),
The Wild Rose (1902),
Mr. Bluebeard (1903),
Piff! Paff!! Pouf!!! (1904),
The Earl and the Girl (1905),
The Orchid (1907),
Mr Hamlet of Broadway (1908/9),
Up and Down Broadway (1910), and
Over the River (1912). It was while on tour with
Mr. Bluebeard that he became a hero of Chicago's infamous
Iroquois Theatre fire, December 30, 1903. A malfunctioning spotlight set fire to the scenery backstage, and Foy stayed onstage until the last minute, trying to keep the audience from panicking. Survivors later praised Foy for his bravery in trying to keep the crowd calm, even as burning debris fell onto the stage all around him. The theater's safety features were inadequate, the theater personnel untrained, and some of the exits locked from the outside, and at least 600 people died. Foy escaped by crawling through a sewer. ==Eddie Foy and The Seven Little Foys==