Four years after Cridge arrived in Victoria, in 1859, the
Diocese of British Columbia was formed from the
Diocese of Rupert's Land that had covered all of Canada west of Ontario. English priest George Hills was made the first bishop and arrived in Victoria in January 1860. Cridge and Hills were wary of each other, with Cridge a low church evangelical and Hills somewhere between a "moderate high churchman" (according to Julie H. Ferguson) and an "ardent Tractarian" (according to
Allen C. Guelzo). Hills immediately set up another congregation in Victoria and ordered a prefabricated iron frame structure for it, a decision that irked many of the local Anglicans who worried the town could not yet support two churches. However, despite their disagreements, Hills and Cridge were able to coexist since Hills was often absent from Victoria performing episcopal duties throughout his diocese and traveling back and forth to England to raise funds for the diocese. In 1865, Hills designated Christ Church as the cathedral of the diocese, making Cridge the first
dean of Columbia. However, according to Ferguson, their correspondence and diaries show growing hostility between the bishop and his dean. In 1869, the first Christ Church burned and was rebuilt. The December 5, 1872, dedication service of the new cathedral triggered a definitive break between Hills and Cridge. Hills assigned the newly appointed
archdeacon of
Vancouver, William Sheldon Reece, to preach at the
evensong dedication service. Reece preached from Luke 24:52-53, to endorse the sacramental focus of the Oxford Movement. As dean, Cridge was presiding over the service and was to announce the post-sermon hymn; instead, Cridge stood and condemned the sermon. "My dearly beloved friends, it is with the greatest shame and humiliation that as a matter of conscience I feel it is my duty to say a few words to you before we part," he said. As your pastor, after what we have just heard I feel it is my duty to raise up my voice in protest against it... During the seventeen years that I have officiated as your pastor in this spot, this is the first time ritualism has been preached here; and I pray, Almighty God, it may be the last. So far as I can prevent it, it shall be the last. After Cridge's rebuke, most of the congregation and much of Victoria sided with the local rector over Bishop Hills, who took Cridge's statement as a personal rebuke and demanded an apology. Hills avoided Christ Church for several months, but in July 1873, he announced that he would make an episcopal visit to his cathedral. When the day came, Cridge and a warden blocked Hills from entering the cathedral. After several months of correspondence and increasingly public disputes—Hills from the pulpit, with Cridge responding in newspaper columns—the argument extended to Cridge resisting Hills' efforts to call the first diocesan synod in early 1874. Cridge wrote to Hills that "every congregation, with its accepted pastor, is a complete church ... that the scriptures alone are binding on the consciences of churchmen, and therefore are the virtual law." He added that "the only accountable and lawful expounder and interpreter of this law ... is the pastor of the congregation ... to whom not even the Bishop can dictate"—a position that Anglican archivist Frank Peake called "completely untenable" in an
episcopal polity. Finally, in September 1874, Hills held an
ecclesiastical trial and suspended Cridge from ministry. According to Ferguson, Cridge believed he was being rebuked for his evangelical convictions, while Hills was focused on the issue of canonical disobedience. (Cridge offered to make an apology, but without acknowledging Hills' prerogative to demand one.) The wardens of Christ Church refused to accept the suspension and invited Cridge to take services at the cathedral. Hills sought a civil court ruling to enforce the ecclesiastical trial outcome, and on October 24, the
Supreme Court of British Columbia issued an injunction that barred Cridge from the cathedral. Three days later, three-fourths of the congregation joined Cridge in leaving to form a new congregation. "We are not seceding from the Anglican Church," Cridge told his new flock, insisting instead that Hills had "virtually seceded from the Anglican Church, and tried to draw the congregation with him; up to last Sunday week we all were more nearly connected with the Anglican Church (with all respect) than the Bishop himself." The new congregation—which would become known as
Church of Our Lord—drew 400 worshippers on its first Sunday, including most of the key personnel of the cathedral and Governor Douglas. ==Reformed Episcopal Church==