Whittall began playing football at
Bournabat FC, which had been founded in
Bornova in the late 1880s by several young merchants from the vast colony of Westerners living in
Levant, specifically of British and French nationality, such as prominent members of the wealthy Whithall and La Fontaine families residing in Izmir; in fact, in Bournabat's first-ever recorded match in 1894, the club fielded several members of those families, including his uncle
Herbert and his older brother
Albert, who played a crucial role in helping Bournabat became the strongest team in Smyrna in the 1890s. In 1904, Edward and his brother Albert started for a Smyrna XI in an inter-city match against
Istanbul, helping their side to a 4–2 victory. Aged 17 years and 352 days, he was not only the youngest player in the team, but also the youngest of the tournament. At the Olympics, Smyrna were knocked-out in the semifinals by a
Copenhagen XI (5–1), who went on claim gold, but the withdrawal of the Athens team during the final and their subsequent disqualification meant that Smyrna and
Thessaloniki would face each other for second place on 25 April 1906, in which the Whittalls, who formed a powerful attacking quintet, played a crucial role in helping their side to a 12–0 victory, thus winning the silver medal, which still is the greatest success of Izmir football in official matches. ==Later life and death==