Nomination and confirmation and Deputy National Security Advisor
Pavan Kapoor in May 2025. Colby considers India to be a model ally. On December 22, 2024, President-elect Trump nominated Colby to serve as the
under secretary of defense for policy for his second term as president. Despite the support of influential
MAGA figures like
Vice President JD Vance and influencer
Charlie Kirk, his nomination drew criticism from Republican Party
defense hawks like Senator
Tom Cotton regarding his past comments that
Iran's acquisition of a nuclear weapon would not be an existential risk for the United States. During his hearing before the
United States Senate Committee on Armed Services on March 4, 2025, Colby said he would not hesitate to advise Trump on military options to stop
Iran's nuclear program if necessary. He also confirmed his intention to increase U.S. military resources in the
Indo-Pacific and called on
Taiwan to increase its defense budget from 2.5% of GDP to 10%. Colby's nomination was confirmed by a 54–45 Senate vote on April 8, 2025. Senator
Mitch McConnell was the only Republican to oppose Colby's nomination, leading to criticism from Republicans including
JD Vance and
Nate Morris.
Tenure In May 2025, Colby told British officials that the United States wanted the
British Armed Forces to focus less on the
Indo-Pacific and more in the Euro-Atlantic region. He also expressed concern about the UK sending the
HMS Prince of Wales to the Indo-Pacific. In June 2025, Colby pushed for the Department of Defense to launch a review whether to scrap the
AUKUS agreement with Australia and the United Kingdom. Colby also pushed for Japan to increase its military spending to 3.5% of its GDP, which led Japan to cancel a meeting between U.S. secretary of state
Marco Rubio and U.S. defense secretary
Pete Hegseth and Japanese Defense Minister
Gen Nakatani and Foreign Minister
Takeshi Iwaya in
Washington, D.C. In early July, the US paused deliveries of various munitions to
Ukraine, an initiative that reportedly originated from Colby; both Congress and the
State Department were not aware of the decision. Additionally, members within the Trump administration were not consulted on the halting of the arms shipments, with Trump himself claiming to be unaware of the decision. Trump later reinstated the arms shipments within days. Afterwards, a bi-partisan group of members of Congress demanded an explanation from Colby. After the
European-White House crisis meeting was held in August 2025, Trump announced the US could provide security guarantees to Ukraine as part of a peace agreement to end the
Russo-Ukrainian war. Colby reportedly told representatives of European allies that the US would play a minimal role in any security guarantees. Later that month, Ukraine was denied long-range missile strikes on Russia under a “review mechanism” that had been developed by Colby. During a
Senate Armed Services Committee hearing held in November 2025, several Republican Senators criticized Colby's office for failure to communicate policy with members of Congress. During the hearing to confirm
Austin Dahmer as
Assistant Secretary of Defense for Strategy, Plans, and Capabilities, Senator
Dan Sullivan of
Alaska stated "I can't even get a response, and we're on your team" claiming that it was more difficult to get a response from Colby than it was to speak with Defense Secretary
Pete Hegseth or even President Trump. Sullivan added that Colby "has been really bad on this. The worst in the administration...". Senator
Roger Wicker of
Mississippi agreed, stating that Colby's policy office specifically had been unusually difficult about information sharing relative to other organs of the Defense Department, while Senator
Tom Cotton of
Arkansas characterized Colby's office as a "pigpen-like mess", regarding communication. On 5 November, the Pentagon denied Colby had been purposely withholding information from Congress.
Kingsley Wilson, the Pentagon's spokesperson, stated that Colby's team had "briefed Congress dozens of times, in both classified and unclassified settings, in addition to other meetings."
Reuters described the incident as a "rare bipartisan show of frustration with the administration." In December 2025, the
Financial Times reported that many within the administration of Japanese Prime Minister
Sanae Takaichi felt "deep disappointment" over a lack of public support she received from Trump over remarks about defending
Taiwan, after she stated that a Chinese invasion of Taiwan would constitute a "survival threatening situation" to Japan and prompt a response from the
Japan Self-Defense Forces. This came after Colby had been reportedly pushing Japan to take such a stance.
2026 meeting with Cardinal Christophe Pierre In April 2026,
The Free Press reported that on January 22, 2026, Colby summoned Cardinal
Christophe Pierre to an "unprecedented" closed door "lecture" at the Pentagon. According to
The Free Press, Colby, along with several colleagues, used the meeting to criticize Pope Leo XIV's annual "state of the world" speech given in January 2026, and told Pierre that the United States "has the military power to do whatever it wants—and that the Church had better take its side." Another official invoked the
Avignon Papacy, a period during the 1300s where the
French Monarchy used its military power to control the papacy. ==Political views==