After his return to New Echota, in 1828 Boudinot was selected by the General Council of the Cherokee as editor for a newspaper, the first to be published by a Native American nation. He worked with a new friend
Samuel Worcester, a missionary and printer. Worcester had new type created and cast for the new forms of the Cherokee
syllabary. In 1828, the two printed the
Cherokee Phoenix in Cherokee and English. While planned as a bi-lingual newspaper, the
Phoenix published most of its articles in English; under Boudinot, about 16 percent of the content was published in Cherokee. The journalist Ann Lackey Landini believes that Boudinot emphasized English in the newspaper because the Cherokee Nation intended it to be a means to explain their people to European Americans and prove they had an admirable civilization. At the same time, the Council intended it to unite the Cherokee through the Southeast. The
Phoenix regularly published new laws and other national Cherokee political information in the paper. Between 1828 and 1832, Boudinot wrote numerous editorials arguing against
removal, as proposed by Georgia and supported by President
Andrew Jackson. After Congress passed the
Indian Removal Act of 1830, federal pressure on the Cherokee increased. Jackson supported removal of the Cherokee and other Southeastern peoples from their eastern homelands to
Indian Territory west of the Mississippi in order to make land available for European-American development. Over a roughly four-year period, Boudinot's editorials emphasized that Georgia's disregard of the Constitution and past federal treaties with the Cherokee would not only hurt Cherokee progress in acculturating, but threatened the fabric of the Union. Boudinot's articles recounted the elements of Cherokee assimilation (conversion to Christianity, an increasingly Western-educated population, and a turn toward lives as herdsmen and farmers, etc.) He criticized the "easy" way in which treaty language was distorted by Indian Removal advocates for their own purposes. In 1832, while on a speaking tour of
the North to raise funds for the
Phoenix, Boudinot learned that, in
Worcester v. Georgia, the
US Supreme Court had sustained the Cherokee rights to political and territorial sovereignty within Georgia's borders. He soon learned that President Jackson still supported Indian Removal. In this context, Boudinot began advocating for his people to secure the best possible terms with the US by making a binding treaty of removal, as he believed it was inevitable. His changed position was widely opposed by the Cherokee. The National Council and
John Ross, the Principal Chief, opposed removal, as did the majority of the people. Former allies in the Cherokee government turned against Boudinot and other "treaty advocates," who included John Ridge and Major Ridge. Opponents attacked the men's loyalty and prevented their speaking in councils. Ross denounced Boudinot's "toleration of diversified views in the
Cherokee Phoenix and forbade Boudinot from discussing pro-removal arguments in the paper. In protest, Boudinot resigned in the spring of 1832. Ross' brother-in-law, Elijah Hicks, replaced Boudinot as editor. In 1959, he was inducted into the
Georgia Newspaper Hall of Fame in recognition of his newspaper work. ==Literary works==