Her solo show about relationships,
This Feels Terrible, premiered at UCB in 2010. It later became a podcast, with McGathy interviewing comedians and friends about their relationships. Notable guests included comedians
Marc Maron,
Dan Harmon,
Wayne Federman, and director
Rob Schrab. McGathy became a frequent guest and "comptroller" on the
Harmontown podcast. McGathy was a regular character on the show's
Dungeons & Dragons segment and subsequently a cast member in the spin-off animated series from
Seeso,
HarmonQuest. Beginning in March 2015, McGathy co-hosts the podcast
Human Conversation with comedian Wayne Federman, in which the two discuss various, oft-delightful and meandering topics, without the aid of technology. She co-founded the MOB theatre troupe in Dublin in 2018, and the following year debuted at the
Dublin Fringe Festival her solo theatrical show,
Al Dawes F***ing Loves You , in which she played a whimsical
beta male comedian going through a break-up. ==Personal life==