Evans ended up becoming one of the all-time best special teams players at Wingate, in his stint spanning from the 2019 season to 2022. Evans had his best season as a
senior, posting 67 kickoffs for 4,180 yards with a 62.4 average and 44
touchbacks, and 77 punts for 3,518 yards, averaging 45.69 yards per punt, a total that ranked second-best in the
NCAA Division II. He additionally had 39 punts inside the 20 and 30 that went more than 50 yards, and went 10-for-18 on field goals with a long of 41, as well as 43-of-44 on extra points. Evans twice was named the national player of the week by D2Football.com and was named first-team all-conference, all-region, and a D2CCA first-team
All-American. He also was named first-team All-American by
Associated Press (AP), being one of three Wingate players to earn the honor that year. Evans finished his career at Wingate having appeared in 39 games and made 186 punts for 8,027 yards (averaging 43.2 yards per punt) with a long of 72 yards. He had 47 fair catches, 53 punts of more than 50 yards and 89 inside the 20-yard line. Additionally, on kickoffs, he posted 213 kicks for 13,230 yards (an average of 62.1) with 120 touchbacks. Evans was invited to the
Hula Bowl and was also one of only four Division II players to be chosen for the
East–West Shrine Bowl in 2023. ==Professional career==