Box office There were large audiences in Sweden at showings of
Fanny and Alexander, including at the five-hour cut, making it the most popular box-office film Bergman had in his native country. It had 374,208 admissions in France and 165,146 in Germany. This amounted to minimal presence in the French box-office.
Fanny and Alexander finished its run grossing $6,783,304 in North America. In 1992,
Variety ranked it the 21st highest grossing foreign film in U.S. box office history, and the fifth-highest grossing Swedish film after 1967's
I Am Curious (Yellow) and
Elvira Madigan,
Dear John (1964) and
My Life as a Dog (1985).
Critical reception Upon release in Sweden, the film received generally positive reviews, with
Expressen critic Lasse Bergström approving of the portrayal of the
Oscarian era. Critic
Stig Larsson assessed it as Bergman's ironic take on his past filmography.
Jönköpings-Posten posted a positive review on 7 February 1983, followed by a second critic in the same paper accusing the film of creating false joy on 21 February. The film ranked 10th on
Cahiers du Cinéma's
Top 10 Films of the Year List in 1983. Vincent Canby's contemporary review in
The New York Times described it a "big, dark, beautiful, generous family chronicle"; Canby also praised the cast as "uniformly excellent".
Roger Ebert awarded it four stars, assessing it as "a big, exciting, ambitious film", relatable to audiences though more specific in its story than Bergman's prior studies of faith and sex, and named it the 4th best film of 1983.
Variety staff called it "a sumptuously produced period piece" blending "elegance with intimacy". For
The Washington Post, Rita Kempley found the story more cheerful than past Bergman productions, highlighting Ewa Fröling and comparing her to Liv Ullmann. In
The New York Times, Michiko Kakutani compared the film's "generosity of vision" to the
comedies of William Shakespeare.
The Nation critic Robert Hatch compared it to Shakespeare's
The Tempest as a final life-affirming work, featuring "magic with the casual authority of
Prospero himself".
Kerry Brougher denied it was Bergman's
magnum opus, but still said it was "a thoughtful, graceful, beautifully filmed work".
National Review critic John Simon wrote a negative review, calling it "overstuffed", and expressing lack of interest in Fröling and Guve as newcomers to Bergman's filmography. Ebert added it to his
Great Movies list in 2004, hailing it as "astonishingly beautiful", crediting
Sven Nykvist for "color and warmth". In 2010,
The Guardian ranked the film eighth in its list of 25 greatest
arthouse films. Reviewing The Criterion Collection Blu-ray, Andre Dellamorte wrote that despite the five-hour runtime, the story was uncomplicated but always interesting.
The Observer quoted actor
Matthew Macfadyen as saying the film "featured just the most extraordinary acting I'd ever seen". Macfadyen added that as a
RADA student, the film was shown as "an example to follow – an example of people acting with each other". Polish film director
Agnieszka Holland also praised it in 2012, saying both children and intellectuals could enjoy it and that it gives a very vivid portrait of another era. In his
2015 Movie Guide,
Leonard Maltin gave it four stars, identifying its emotions as "exquisitely expressed".
Pauline Kael wrote a more mixed review, enjoying the merry atmosphere but writing the "conventionality" is "rather shocking", suggesting Bergman had moved to Victorian times to escape his usual eccentric viewpoints.
The Guardian critic Alex Cox wrote a negative review in 2006, claiming there was no story for the first two of three hours, and that the analogy to
Hamlet did not hold up as Alexander knows Edvard is evil, whereas Hamlet is uncertain if the Ghost is a demon and Claudius is innocent. Cox had not seen the longer version, but considered it might be better. In 1990,
Fanny and Alexander was named the best film of the 1980s by
Los Angeles Times by
Sheila Benson, who called it "generous, ribald, reflective and radiantly life-affirming", and Michael Wilmington, and the third best by
Newsweek critic David Ansen. In 2004,
The New York Times also included the film on its list of "the Best 1,000 Movies Ever Made". Xan Brooks, in
The Guardians Film Season, chose the film as the eighth "best arthouse film of all time". He described it as "an opulent family saga, by turns bawdy, stark and strange" with a rare abundance of "indelible supporting characters". In 2007, the film was ranked at No. 23 by
The Guardians readers' poll on its list of "40 greatest foreign films of all time". The film was Voted at No. 44 on the list of "100 Greatest Films" by the prominent French magazine
Cahiers du cinéma in 2008. In the
British Film Institute's 2012
Sight & Sound polls of the greatest films ever made,
Fanny and Alexander was 84th among critics and 16th among directors. In the earlier 2002 version of the list, the film ranked 35th among critics and 19th among directors. Also in 2002,
Sight and Sound magazine invited several critics to make a list of the best films of last 25 years and
Fanny and Alexander was ranked at number three. In 2012 the film was voted at number five on the 25 best Swedish films of all-time list by a poll of 50 film critics and academics conducted by film magazine FLM. In 2018, the film was ranked 28th in BBC's list of The 100 greatest foreign language films. In 2022 edition of Sight & Sound's
Greatest films of all time list the film ranked 53rd in the director's poll.
Fanny and Alexander has a
100% approval rating on
Rotten Tomatoes, based on 45 reviews, with a
weighted average of 9/10. The site's consensus reads: "Ingmar Bergman conveys the sweep of childhood with a fastidious attention to detail and sumptuous insight into human frailty in
Fanny and Alexander, a masterwork that crystalizes many of the directors' preoccupations into a familial epic". On
Metacritic, the film has a weighted average score of 100 out of 100 based on 8 critics, indicating "universal acclaim".
Accolades The film received six
Academy Award nominations, winning four, including
Best Foreign Language Film. It also received the third highest number of nominations of 1984, after
Terms of Endearment and
The Right Stuff (both released in 1983). The four wins was the most any foreign-language film had received at the Academy Awards to date until it tied the record with
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (
2000),
Parasite (
2019) and
All Quiet on the Western Front (
2022).
Fanny and Alexander marked the third and final time Bergman won Best Foreign Language Film, after
The Virgin Spring (1960) and
Through a Glass Darkly (1961). Bergman did not personally attend the ceremony, while working on a stage production in
Munich, so his award was accepted by his wife Ingrid von Rosen and Jörn Donner. The film won the
FIPRESCI Prize at
1983 Venice Film Festival. It also won the
French Syndicate of Cinema Critics Award for Best Foreign Film. ==Legacy==