Critical response After a string of box office flops, John Huston rebounded with this film, which opened to tremendous praise and good business, and he was soon in demand for more work.
Vincent Canby, film critic for
The New York Times, liked the film and Huston's direction. He wrote, "This is grim material but
Fat City is too full of life to be as truly dire as it sounds. Ernie and Tully, along with Oma (
Susan Tyrrell), the sherry-drinking barfly Tully shacks up with for a while, the small-time fight managers, the other boxers and assorted countermen, upholsterers, and lettuce pickers whom the film encounters en route, are presented with such stunning and sometimes comic accuracy that
Fat City transcends its own apparent gloom."
Roger Ebert made the case for it as one of Huston's best films. He also appreciated the performances. Ebert wrote, "[Huston] treats [the story] with a level, unsentimental honesty and makes it into one of his best films...[and] the movie's edges are filled with small, perfect character performances."
J. Hoberman of
The Village Voice wrote, "The movie is crafty work and very much a show. In one way or another, right down to the percussively abrupt open ending, it's all about being hammered."
Dave Kehr of the
Chicago Reader wrote, "John Huston's 1972 restatement of his theme of perpetual loss is intelligently understated." Film critic Dennis Schwartz wrote, "The downbeat sports drama is a marvelous understated character study of the marginalized leading desperate lives, where they have left themselves no palpable way out. The stunning photography by
Conrad Hall keeps things looking realistic." Reportedly, after a showing of this movie, champion boxer
Muhammad Ali apparently said to Huston: "Man that's for real, that's me talking up there." In 2009,
Fat City enjoyed a week-long revival screening at
New York City's
Film Forum. It has a 100% fresh rating on
Rotten Tomatoes, based on 27 reviews. The site's consensus reads: "
Fat City is a bleak, mordant, slice of life boxing drama that doesn't pull its punches". Filmmaker
Spike Lee has reportedly added
Fat City to his list of "essential films" for film students to watch at
NYU. The drama is featured in the documentary
Visions of Light: The Art of Cinematography (1992) for
Conrad L. Hall's use of lighting.
Awards and nominations Wins •
Kansas City Film Critics Circle: KCFCC Award Best Actor
Stacy Keach, (tied with
Marlon Brando for
The Godfather); 1972. •
Belgian Film Critics Association:
Grand Prix; 1974.
Nominations •
Academy Awards:
Best Actress in a Supporting Role, Susan Tyrrell; 1973.
New York Film Critics Circle Under the then-extant rules, Stacy Keach should have been awarded
Best Actor from the
New York Film Critics Circle for his portrayal of Tully because it required only a plurality of the vote at the
1972 New York Film Critics Circle Awards. Keach was the top vote-getter for Best Actor. At the time, the NYCC was second in prestige only to the
Academy Awards and was a major influence on subsequent Oscar nominations. A vocal faction of the NYFCC, dismayed by the rather low percentage of votes that would have given Keach the award, successfully demanded a rule change so that the winner would have to obtain a majority. In subsequent balloting, Keach failed to win a majority of the vote, and he lost ground to the performance of Marlon Brando in
The Godfather. However, Brando could not gain a majority either. As a compromise candidate,
Laurence Olivier in
Sleuth eventually was awarded Best Actor. ==See also==