Critical response Roger Ebert of the
Chicago Sun-Times awarded the film stars of four; while he complimented parts of the film and the directing, he was dismissive of the plot, writing in his review that the film is "so preposterous and posturing, so filled with gaps of logic and continuity, that if it weren't so solemn there'd be the temptation to laugh aloud."
Gene Siskel of the
Chicago Tribune gave the film three stars out of four and wrote that it "may leave you punch drunk, knocked out by its visuals to the point of missing what a simple story it is."
Richard Eder of
The New York Times praised the film, writing, "There are quite a few science-fiction movies scheduled to come out in the next year or so. We shall be lucky if even one or two are as absorbing and as beautiful as
The Man Who Fell to Earth." Writing for
The New Yorker,
Pauline Kael described the film as "
The Little Prince for young adults, the hero, a stranger on earth, is purity made erotic" and describes
Bowie as a "the most romantic figure in recent pictures, the modern version of the
James Dean lost-boy myth." Robert Hawkins, reviewing for
Variety, praised Roeg's direction and felt the film was "stunning stuff throughout, and Bowie's choice as the ethereal visitor is inspired...Candy Clark, as his naive but loving mate, confirms the winning ways that won her an Oscar nomination in
American Graffiti. Her intimate scenes with Bowie, especially the introductory ones, are among pic's highlights."
Charles Champlin of the
Los Angeles Times described Bowie as "perfect casting" but thought the film was "a muddle," and suspected it was because he reviewed a version trimmed by 20 minutes for its U.S. run: "That would do a lot to explain why the movie proceeds from the provocatively cryptic to the merely incomprehensible." In a retrospective review,
Kim Newman of
Empire gave the movie five stars out of five, describing the film as "consistently disorientating and beguilingly beautiful." Review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes reports the film has a 79% approval rating based on 71 reviews with an average rating of 7.80/10. The critics' consensus states: "Filled with stunning imagery,
The Man Who Fell to Earth is a calm, meditative film that profoundly explores our culture's values and desires." On
Metacritic, the film has achieved a
weighted average rating of 81 out of 100 from 9 critic reviews, citing "universal acclaim".
Legacy Since its original 1976 release,
The Man Who Fell to Earth has achieved
cult status. This status has been echoed by critics, especially as it was a popular hit with
midnight movie audiences years after it was released. Joshua Rothkopf of
Time Out believed that the cult classic status, which he described as a "vaguely demeaning term", does the film a disservice. He labeled the film as "the most intellectually provocative genre film of the 1970s." When re-released in 2011, Ebert gave the film three stars, stating that readers should "consider this just a quiet protest vote against the way projects this ambitious are no longer possible in the mainstream movie industry."
Rolling Stone ranked it second on its 50 best sci-fi movies of the 1970s,
Timeout ranked it 35th on its 100 best sci-fi movies, it is 61st on the
Online Film Critics Society list of "greatest science fiction films of all time".
Empire placed it 42nd on its list of 100 best British films.
British Film Institute included it on its list of "50 late night classics", demonstrating its popularity as a midnight movie.
Filmink noted the movie "features a scene where a woman talks to Rip Torn’s penis, and we see Candy Clark from every possible angle." It also led to Bowie being cast by
Jack Hofsiss in the play
The Elephant Man. Hofsiss said: "The piece of work he did that was most helpful in making the decision was
The Man Who Fell To Earth, in which I thought he was wonderful, and in which the character he played had an isolation similar to the Elephant Man's".
Accolades == In popular culture ==