The episode opens during the ending of
that day's episode of
The Daily Show, with
Jon Stewart checking in with
Stephen to "toss over" the show (a discontinued practice used earlier in the series run). Colbert does not directly acknowledge it being the final episode, but he quickly has
Jimmy start
The Colbert Report, abruptly ending
The Daily Show without closing credits or a
Moment of Zen. He started the show with a quip: "If this is your first time tuning into The Colbert Report, I have some terrible news." The first segment begins with a news story about a truck from Mark I Plumbing now being used as an
anti-aircraft gun in
Syria. Colbert continues by announcing the winners of the auction for his desk and fireplace set from the show's one-on-one interview area, which collectively accumulated a total of
$313,420 for the
Yellow Ribbon Fund and
DonorsChoose. He then starts the final installment of "
The Wørd" segment with "Same to You, Pal", including a series of clips features memorable moments and ventures done by Stephen over the past nine years. After returning from a commercial break, Stephen begins the final installment of "
Cheating Death with Dr. Stephen T. Colbert, D.F.A." The opening of the segment deviates right away when "
Grimmy" tries to kill Stephen after watching him cheat in their chess match. Colbert draws his pistol Sweetness and kills "Grimmy" on the spot, throwing his pistol into the crowd with a fan getting it, leaving him without a guest and making him
immortal. Returning from another commercial break, Stephen explains he was going to say goodbye before ending the series, but now that he has become immortal, he realizes it would be meaningless and begins singing the song "
We'll Meet Again." Soon after, he is immediately joined by Jon Stewart; as the song proceeds, the studio continues to fill rapidly with
several recognizable figures who have been involved in the show throughout its run. After the song ends, the studio is now empty, with a painting without Stephen Colbert, and Stephen is on the roof of the studio questioning what he should do now.
Santa Claus' sleigh suddenly lands in front of him; Santa is accompanied by a
unicorn-hybrid
Abraham Lincoln, and
Alex Trebek, "
the man with all the answers". Stephen agrees to join them, but worries that this means he will be gone forever. Trebek assures Stephen that they will always be there for the American people
when they need them the most. The episode ends with Colbert thanking everyone involved in the show throughout the run, and he calls upon
Mavis Staples to help do so. Signing off with the words, "From Eternity, I'm Stephen Colbert," he then throws the show back to Jon Stewart, paying homage to his character's beginnings on
The Daily Show and hinting that the entire series was just a nine-year-long correspondent segment. Jon thanks Stephen for the report and introduces the
Moment of Zen, which is a previously unaired clip of Stewart checking in with Colbert from June 3, 2010. After being told that the said footage will not be used on air, Stewart says, "let's go back into our funny characters ... Stephen, what are you doing?" To which Colbert mockingly replies, "Hi Jon, I'm getting angry at
liberals". The show's closing credits were played with the song "
Holland, 1945" by
Neutral Milk Hotel instead of the usual theme; Colbert picked the song in honor of his father and two brothers, who died in a
plane crash. ==Background==