Prior to the release of
Fingerprints, there was some talk of the idea that a
best-of album would be a mistake by the band, as they were generally seen as the "end of an artist's creative haul".
MTV Scene writer Craig Tangsley also commented on fears about the "death" of the band, stating that he spoke to
Bernard Fanning about the band's death as "it's inevitable to talk when someone releases a best[-]of album".
Ciao reviewer cocoklo agreed with Universal's assessment, stating that "If there ever was a band, in my opinion, that needed a greatest hits album, it's Powderfinger". Throughout production stages, the album was not referred to as
Fingerprints: The Best of Powderfinger, 1994–2000 but rather by its alternative title,
From Heavy Metal to Centenary Medal. It is unknown when the band decided on the final title of the album. == Album and single releases ==