The show was originally hosted and moderated by
Jay Crawford and
Dana Jacobson, formerly of the show's predecessor
Cold Pizza. In August 2011, the show underwent a drastic format change. Segments of the show were taken out and Skip Bayless' role in the show saw a dramatic increase, while the show itself began to focus on the debate. The ratings for the show saw a drastic increase as a result, with a reported 58% increase for the first 3 months of 2012, compared to the same time in 2011. On April 30, 2012, it was announced on-air that regular guest contributor
Stephen A. Smith would be joining
First Take on a permanent, five-day-per-week basis. On occasions he was reporting from elsewhere,
Rob Parker was frequently featured as his replacement until December 20, 2012, when he was suspended for comments made about
Robert Griffin III; he would not return, as ESPN allowed his contract to expire, rather than re-sign him. In June 2012, long-time host Crawford announced he would be leaving
First Take in order to present
SportsCenter. On July 23, 2012, the show debuted a new set and a new opening song
Every Word Great by
Wale featuring
Stalley. It now featured an open slideshow showing Bayless and Smith arriving at campus (Once Kellerman joined the show in 2016, scenes showing Kellerman replaced those of Bayless). They are still in Studio E but they are in the middle of it, with a new desk. In line with these changes,
First Take introduced on October 1, 2012 a new permanent moderator,
Cari Champion, previously a reporter from the
Tennis Channel. Previously, the show had a rotation of moderators, such as
Todd Grisham, Don Bell (now Sports Director & anchor with Philadelphia's
KYW-TV),
Cindy Brunson (now with
Fox Sports Arizona) and
Jemele Hill. On January 13, 2015, the first special edition of the show aired after the
2015 College Football Playoff National Championship titled
First Take: College Football Championship Post Game Special. On June 19, 2015, Champion left
First Take due to her promotion to
SportsCenter anchor. The following month, she was replaced on an interim basis by
Molly Qerim, who was promoted to permanent host on September 15. On July 25, 2016,
Max Kellerman permanently replaced Skip Bayless as the
First Take co-host as Bayless had left ESPN to join rival network
FS1 and started another sports talk program called
Skip and Shannon: Undisputed. On January 3, 2017,
First Take switched channels with the two editions of
SportsCenter.
First Take moved to ESPN, while the 10:00 a.m. and 11:00 a.m. ET editions of
SportsCenter moved to ESPN2. In September 2018, the show moved to ESPN's New York studios, and received a new logo and graphics as part of the move. In 2021, Kellerman left
First Take to allow for a new format involving rotating guest analysts appearing alongside Smith. Kellerman's last day on the show was September 1. Smith later revealed that he wanted Kellerman off of
First Take as he believed the two of them lacked the chemistry they once had, although he clarified that there were no hard feelings towards Kellerman: "I wasn't pointing a finger at him. I was saying we did not work as a pair." In September 2025, it was reported that Qerim would be leaving ESPN at the end of 2025 after declining a contract renewal with the network. Qerim later confirmed the news on her
Instagram account. Qerim said that she had "the privilege of sharing the desk with some of the most brilliant, passionate, and entertaining voices in sports," and that hosting the show "has been one of the greatest honors of my career." Qerim did not appear on
First Take after her announcement, with Stephen A. Smith announcing on his radio show that she had "abruptly resigned" as host. She was eventually replaced by
Shae Cornette, starting in November. ==Controversy==