Friedel's salt could be first tentatively represented as an
AFm phase in which two chloride ions would have simply replaced one sulfate ion. This conceptual representation based on the intuition of a simple stoichiometric exchange is very convenient to remind but such a simple mechanism likely does not directly occur and must be considered with caution: : Indeed, the reality appears to be more complex than such a simple stoichiometric exchange between chloride and sulfate ions in the AFm
crystal structure. In fact, it seems that chloride ions are electrostatically sorbed onto the positively charged [Ca2Al(OH)6 · 2H2O]+ layer of AFm hydrate, or could also exchange with hydroxide ions (OH–) also present in the interlayer. So, the simple and "apparent" exchange reaction first presented here above for the sake of ease does not correspond to the reality and is an oversimplified representation. Similarly, Kuzel’s salt could seem to be formed when only 1 Cl– ion exchanges with in AFm (half substitution of sulfate ions): : Glasser
et al. (1999) proposed to name this half-substituted salt in honor of his discoverer:
Hans-Jürgen Kuzel. However, Mesbah et al. (2011) have identified two different types of interlayers in the crystallographic structure they have determined and it precludes the common anion exchange reaction presented here above as stated by the authors themselves in their conclusions: Kuzel's salt is a two-stage layered compound with two distinct interlayers, which are alternatively filled by chloride anions only (for one kind of interlayer) and by sulfate anions and water molecules (for the other kind of interlayer). Kuzel's salt structure is composed of the perfect intercalation of the Friedel's salt structure and the monosulfoaluminate structure (the two end-members of the studied bi-anionic AFm compound). The structural properties of Kuzel's salt explain the absence of extended chloride to sulfate or sulfate to chloride substitution. The staging feature of Kuzel's salt certainly explains the difficulties to substitute chloride and sulfate: the modification in one kind of interlayer involves a modification in the other kind of interlayer in order to preserve the electroneutrality of the compound. The two-stage feature of Kuzel's salt implies that each interlayer should be mono-anionic. So, if the global chemical composition of Friedel's salt and Kuzel's salt corresponds well respectively with the stoichiometry of a complete substitution, or a half substitution, of sulfate ions by chloride ions in the crystal structure of AFm, it does not tell directly anything on the exact mechanism of anion substitution in this complicated system. Only detailed and well controlled chloride sorption, or anion exchange, experiments with a complete analysis of all the dissolved species present in
aqueous solution (also including OH–, Na+ and Ca2+ ions) can decipher the system. == Discovery ==