Cult accusations Based on Teen Mania's doctrines and behavior, some Christian mental health professionals have labeled it a
cult. A blog published by a former intern, entitled "Recovering Alumni," has raised concerns about recurring
spiritual abuse and health and safety issues at the Honor Academy, publishing firsthand accounts from many other interns alleging mistreatment over the past 15 years to the present. In an interview in the
Tyler Morning Telegraph, the blog's author claimed, based on an email list, that about 200 Honor Academy alumni consider themselves "recovering." The cult accusations were challenged by Christian
countercult apologist
Hank Hanegraaff, who questioned the validity of the Duncans' use of Lifton's Eight Criteria for Thought Reform, stating that "the arguments proffered against TMM could just as easily be used to establish historic Christianity as a thought reform cult. Equally significant is the fact that cult
mind control as a sociological model has been utterly discredited." However, Hanegraaff's assertion contradicts current scholarship such as
Kathleen Taylor's book
Brainwashing: The Science Of Thought Control (
Oxford University Press, 2004), which gives credit to mind control as a sociological and psychological model and distinguishes it from religious faith. In a conference call in February 2014, Ron Luce admitted that "most Recovering Alumni content is true" and said that the ministry had made some changes because of it. Some interns who participated in the event describe it as abusive and authoritarian, questioning the spiritual value of activities like rolling down a hill repeatedly. In response to the KLTV news story, Teen Mania leadership promised to form an independent committee to investigate the charges of safety violations. The committee presented their report to the Honor Academy Administration on June 13, 2011. In a video announcement from his blog, David Hasz, the director of the Honor Academy, explained that ESOAL had "changed dramatically and metamorphosized(sic) over the years" and would now be called PEARL (an acronym for Physical, Emotional, and Relational Learning). Hasz said that the revamped event will be "similar to the last several years," but the military rank names that previously were used have been replaced with team-building names. According to Honor Academy director David Hasz, "PEARL is not designed to be 'the event' that will spiritually change [participants] forever," and is "a small part of the Honor Academy." In a statement, Hasz maintained that "those lessons learned through ESOAL and PEARL will still be taught" at Honor Academy. The intern who founded the Recovering Alumni website says she considers this "a small victory" but remains "concerned about the Teen Mania environment as a whole."
Battle Cry Campaign Teen Mania's
Battle Cry Campaign was criticized by mainstream media for its use of military metaphors and imagery, politicizing faith and cultural issues, and using statistics described as "greatly exaggerated."
Lawsuits Teen Mania was sued by
Compassion International in November 2014, seeking $174,124.73 in damages for breach of contract related to canceled Acquire the Fire events. ==References==