Garden of Delete received generally positive reviews from critics, generally describing it as a radical stylistic change from his previous releases.
AllMusics Heather Phares called the album "some of Lopatin's most intellectually engaging music as well as some of his funniest, darkest, and most cathartic". Kyle Carney of
Exclaim! wrote that the record manages to sound accessible despite its complexities, calling it "a
sound collage like no other". Writing for
Consequence, Sasha Geffen called the album "OPN's most emotional work to date and also his most ridiculous", writing that "[i]ts tragedy is bound up with its humor; its sublimity comes from the places where it feels the most broken." For
The Line of Best Fit, Jennifer Johnson wrote, "
GOD isn't about sensory pleasure. It's about sensory gluttony, auditory overload, and revelling in the difficulty of its pacing." She concluded, "It isn't so much an album as a junk shop: that proverbial collection of oddities whose perceived value reflects more about the patron than it does the owner who placed them there." In a mixed review,
The Guardians Paul McInnes wrote, "Lopatin is never quite able to stand still and enjoy some of the sounds he creates. This remains a project for only a very particular kind of pop picker." In another mixed review, Joseph Burnett in
Dusted magazine wrote that "at its best, you can get lost inside
Garden of Deletes rabbit hole of different directions and unexpected asides, but at other times it's easy to feel shut-out, as if you're looking in at someone's intellectual
ADHD, but he's steadfastly refusing to meet your gaze."
Accolades Garden of Delete was included as one of the year's best albums by a variety of publications. ==Track listing==