Positive On
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film has an approval rating of 98% based on 41 reviews, with an average score of 7/10; the website's "critics consensus" reads: "
GasLand patiently and powerfully outlines alarming problems with modern fuel extraction -- and the horrific public health risks that go along with them." Robert Koehler of
Variety referred to the film as "one of the most effective and expressive environmental films of recent years", saying it "may become to the dangers of natural gas drilling what
Silent Spring was to
DDT." Eric Kohn of
IndieWire wrote: "
Gasland is the paragon of first person activist filmmaking done right. […] By grounding a massive environmental issue in its personal ramifications, Fox turns
Gasland into a remarkably urgent diary of national concerns." A review in the
Denton Record Chronicle said that "Fox decides that his own backyard in Pennsylvania isn’t his exclusive property. […] Set to his own banjo music and clever footage,
Gasland is both sad and scary." The review concluded with the statement: "if your soul isn’t moved by the documentary, yours is a heart of shale." Stewart Nusbaumer of the
Huffington Post said the film "just might take you from outrage right into the fire of action."
Bloomberg News critic Dave Shiflett wrote that Fox "may go down in history as the
Paul Revere of
fracking." Chicago
TimeOut gave
Gasland four out of five stars. In Australia, film critic Julie Riggs called the documentary a "horror movie, and a wake-up call."
Mark Kermode of
BBC Radio 5 Live gave the film a generally positive review, criticizing its similarity to other recent oil documentaries, yet praising its "extraordinary visual kick". He said "it is a very interesting story which is made better by the fact that the visuals of it are very poetic, very lyrical", and felt that its themes and ideas were relevant and well presented.
Fort Worth Business Press writer John-Laurent Tronche talked about the growing number of documentaries "that aim to shed a light on what they call a dirty, destructive practice: shale gas exploration. And although oil and gas supporters have labeled the motion pictures as radical propaganda, a local drilling activist said they’re part of a larger, critical look into an ever-growing industry."
Negative Energy in Depth (EiD), launched by the
Independent Petroleum Association of America, created a web page with a list of factual inaccuracies in the documentary, and produced an associated film titled
TruthLand. In response to the EID's criticisms of the film, the makers of
Gasland offered a rebuttal. In an article for
Forbes magazine, Dr. Michael Economides, a professor of engineering at the
University of Houston and former consultant for energy companies including
Chevron,
Shell, and
Petrobras, commented on the "scene from the upcoming documentary
Gasland, which features a man lighting his faucet water on fire and making the ridiculous claim that natural gas drilling is responsible for the incident. The clip, though attention-getting, is wildly inaccurate and irresponsible. To begin with, the vertical depth separation between drinking water aquifers and reservoir targets for gas production is several thousand feet of impermeable rock. Any interchange between the two, if it were possible, would have happened already in geologic time, measured in tens of millions of years, not in recent history." Subsequent academic studies have proven that the area in which the scene takes place (Weld, Colorado) hydraulic fracturing - particularly due to leaking/damaged bores - had contaminated groundwater. In an article for Movies on Chatham, Dr. Pam Hassebroek, a former petroleum reservoir engineer (Registered Professional Engineer) at both
Exxon Research and Shell, pointed out the long history of oil seeps in surface areas, saying that, in Pennsylvania and New York, surface oil has been documented since at least as far back as the 18th century. She also mentioned that U.S. oil and gas production has benefited from the use of hydraulic fracturing since the 1940s. A documentary rebutting
Gasland's claims,
FrackNation, was successfully funded on
Kickstarter and released in 2013.
Awards Won •
Primetime Emmy Awards:
Outstanding Directing for Nonfiction Programming (
Josh Fox) •
Cinema Eye Honors: Outstanding Achievement in Graphic Design or Animation (Juan Cardarelli, Eric M. Levy, Alex Tyson) •
Environmental Media Awards: Best Documentary (Josh Fox) •
Sundance Film Festival: Special Jury Prize – Documentary (Josh Fox) •
Big Sky Documentary Film Festival: Artistic Vision Award – Feature (Josh Fox) • Thin Line Film Festival: Audience Award • Yale Environmental Film Festival: Grand Jury Prize •
Sarasota Film Festival: Special Jury Prize – Documentary Feature (Josh Fox)
Nominated •
Academy Awards:
Best Documentary Feature (Josh Fox,
Trish Adlesic) •
Writers Guild of America Awards:
Best Documentary Screenplay (Josh Fox) • Primetime Emmy Awards:
Outstanding Writing for Nonfiction Programming (Josh Fox) • Primetime Emmy Awards:
Outstanding Cinematography for Nonfiction Programming (Josh Fox) • Primetime Emmy Awards:
Exceptional Merit in Nonfiction Programming (Trish Adlesic, Josh Fox, Molly Gandour) ==Sequel==