The original
Gateshead club was formed in 1899 as South Shields Adelaide and became members of the
Football League in 1919. In 1930 financial problems saw the club moved to Gateshead, where they adopted the name of their new town. However, the club was voted out of the Football League in 1960 and folded in 1973. History repeated itself as the South Shields club formed to replace the original one was also moved to Gateshead, becoming
Gateshead United in 1974. However, they were dissolved at the end of the
1976–77 season. A new club was established, taking over from United in the
Northern Premier League. The
following season saw the club win the Northern Premier League title and the league's Challenge Shield, earning an immediate return to the (now renamed)
Football Conference. However, they lasted only
one season in the Conference, and were relegated back to the Northern Premier League after finishing bottom of the table. In the 2008–09 season, Gateshead were Conference North runners-up. In 2013–14, the club finished third in the league, qualifying for the promotion play-offs. They beat
Grimsby Town 4–2 on aggregate in the semi-finals, setting up a
Wembley final against
Cambridge United, which they lost 2–1. In the
following season the club reached the third round of the FA Cup for the first time; wins over
Norton United in the first round and
Warrington Town in the second led to a third-round tie with
Premier League side
West Bromwich Albion, with Gateshead losing 7–0. and were demoted to the National League North the following month. The curtailed
2019–20 season saw Gateshead finish seventh (with the league table calculated on points-per-game), qualifying for the play-offs. In
2021–22 Gateshead were National League North champions, earning promotion back to the National League. The
2022–23 season saw them reach the
final of the
FA Trophy at Wembley Stadium, where they lost 1–0 to
FC Halifax Town. After finishing sixth in the National League in
2023–24, the club were barred from competing in the play-offs after failing to meet the entry criteria for the Football League due to not obtaining a "10-year security of tenure" for their stadium. They also reached a second successive FA Trophy
final, this time defeating
Solihull Moors on penalties following a 2–2 draw to win the competition. ==Colours and crest==