20th century Mike Jarvis was hired as head coach in 1990. Led by
Yinka Dare, the Colonials received an at-large bid to the
1993 NCAA tournament, the Colonials first NCAA Tournament appearance since
1961. GW advanced to the Sweet Sixteen before losing to the
Fab Five Michigan team (which later vacated its wins due to NCAA
rule violations). The Colonials would also make NCAA Tournament appearances in
1994,
1996, and
1998 under Jarvis. Jarvis would leave the school in 1998 to accept the head coaching position at St. John's. The school then hired recently fired
Texas head coach,
Thomas Penders. Penders would spend three years at GW, before resigning amidst accusations of NCAA rules violations.
21st century On May 2, 2001, the university hired
Karl Hobbs, who spent eight years as an assistant coach at
Connecticut, as head coach. In 2004, Hobbs led GW to back to the national stage, defeating ninth-ranked
Michigan State and No. 12
Maryland in back-to-back games to win the 2004
BB&T Classic. That year, the men's basketball team went on to win the Atlantic 10 West title and the
Atlantic 10 tournament, earning an automatic bid to the
2005 NCAA tournament. The team received a No. 12 seed, losing to No. 5 seed
Georgia Tech in the First Round. The team began the
2005–06 season ranked 21st in the
Associated Press poll, reaching as high as sixth in the polls and closed out the year ranked 19th in the nation. With a 26–2 going into the
2006 NCAA tournament. They received an at-large bid to the Tournament as a No. 8 seed where they came back from an 18-point second-half deficit to defeat No. 9 seed
UNC-Wilmington. However, in the Second Round, they lost to
Duke, the top overall seed.
J. R. Pinnock was drafted in the
2006 NBA draft and two other Colonials from that team played in the NBA.
Pops Mensah-Bonsu played for the
Dallas Mavericks,
Houston Rockets,
San Antonio Spurs, and
Toronto Raptors and
Mike Hall played for the
Washington Wizards. The
2006–07 basketball season was considered by many to be a rebuilding year for the Colonials after graduating their entire starting front court and losing Pinnock to the NBA. Coach Karl Hobbs and Senior guard Carl Elliott led the team to a 23–8 record, winning the
2007 Atlantic 10 tournament, once again earning an automatic bid to the
NCAA tournament. The Colonials received a No. 11 seed and lost to No. 6-seed
Vanderbilt. The Colonials would struggle the next three years and after finishing the 2010–11 season with a record of 17–14, capped by a disappointing 71–59 overtime loss to
Saint Joseph's in the
conference tournament, Karl Hobbs was dismissed as head coach. On May 11, 2011,
Mike Lonergan, former head coach of
Vermont, was hired to replace Hobbs. The 2011–12 basketball season, Lonergan's first with the Colonials, resulted in a 10–21 record (5–11 in Atlantic 10). By the
2013–14 season, Lonergan had rebuilt the program and finished third in the Atlantic 10 with a 24–8 record (11–5 in Atlantic 10). The team received an at-large bid to the 2014 NCAA Tournament, its first NCAA Tournament since 2007. They received a No. 9 seed in the East Region and would lose to
Memphis in the Second Round (formerly known as the First Round). The Colonials regressed the
following year, finishing 22–12. They did, however, receive a bid to the NIT where they defeated Pittsburgh before losing in the second round to Temple. In
2016, the Colonials again missed the NCAA Tournament and again received a bid to the
NIT. This time the Colonials would defeat
Hofstra,
Monmouth, and
Florida to reach the NIT final four at
Madison Square Garden. In the NIT semifinal, they defeated
San Diego State to advance to the championship game. In the championship game, they cruised to the NIT championship with a 76–60 win over
Valparaiso. However, the Colonials could not build on their NIT success as the school fired head coach Mike Lonergan on September 16, 2016, after an investigation found him guilty of verbally and emotionally abusing his players. The school named assistant coach
Maurice Joseph interim coach for the
2016–17 season. The Colonials finished the 2017 season 20–15, 10–8 in A-10 play and received a bid to the
College Basketball Invitational where they defeated
Toledo in the first round before losing to
UIC.On March 27, 2017, the school removed the interim tag and named Maurice Joseph full-time head coach. Joseph was fired after the 2018–19 season. He had an overall 44–57 record (.436) at GW including 21–33 (.389) in the Atlantic 10. On March 21, 2019, former
Siena head coach
Jamion Christian was hired as the new head coach. Christian accumulated a 29–50 record in three seasons and was let go. On April 1, 2022, longtime George Mason and Miami (FL) assistant
Chris Caputo was hired as the new coach. ==Postseason==