Following the category's announcement,
Polygons Owen S. Good lamented that, given the award's eligibility criteria,
indie games inclusive of LGBT characters and themes such as
Tacoma,
Butterfly Soup, and
Dream Daddy could not be nominated. CJ Adriessen of
Destructoid was disappointed by the inaugural nominees in 2019, arguing that
The Missing: J.J. Macfield and the Island of Memories deserved a nomination given its positive and respectful representation of trans people, Also discussing the category's inaugural nominees, Jay Castello of
Rock Paper Shotgun criticized the inclusion of ''Assassin's Creed Odyssey
, particularly in light of its Legacy of the First Blade'' DLC. Castello argued that—especially given GLAAD's own criticisms of the DLC—
Odyssey "wasn't, in fact, 'outstanding, pointing out how in
Overwatch both
Tracer and
Soldier: 76 are revealed to be queer only in the tie-in comics, outside of the game. she recognized that progress is not a linear process, and described the list as being well-founded. ==Notes==