The track received positive reviews from music critics.
Stephen Thomas Erlewine from
AllMusic, wrote that "darkness hangs heavy [on the album], surfacing fiercely in the clenched-mouth phrasing on 'God Control'."
Varietys Jeremy Helligar deemed it, alongside previous track "
Dark Ballet", as one of the moments in
Madame X where "true weirdness sets in", and "the closest Madonna may ever come to her own '
Bohemian Rhapsody'." Ben Beaumont-Thomas, from
The Guardian, called it one of the album's "shockers suitable only for
schadenfreude lovers or scholars of extreme
camp." He further concluded that "it is – only just – brilliant, and will become an equally beloved and despised curio among fans". Mike Wass from
Idolator, said it was a "daring, successful
experiment ... sprawling and perhaps unnecessarily
baroque, but it burns with ambitious and anger. And still manages to be
pop".
Rolling Stones
Rob Sheffield hailed it as "a rare moment of Madonna understatement". Louise Bruton from
The Irish Times, stated that the song is "an experimental stand against
authoritarianism and gun control through distorted
Black Mirror-style pop ... to basically shake our shoulders and tell us to wake up,
sheeple". Samuel R. Murrian from
Parade ranked it at number 96 on his list of the singer's 100 greatest songs. According to Nicolas Hautman from
Us Weekly, "God Control" is Madonna's "most daring and epic" song since 2012's "
Gang Bang".
Gay Times Daniel Megarry deemed it "creative, dance-able and unexpected ... pure perfection", as well as the best song on the album. Jonny Coleman from
The Hollywood Reporter called the track a "a six-plus-minute odyssey".
Papers Bradley Stern described it as a "happy-go-lucky disco ode to gun control". Sal Cinquemani, from
Slant Magazine, opined it was the "album's
pièce de résistance", as well as "the most exhilaratingly batshit thing she's done in years". For
The Atlantics Spencer Kornhaber, it felt "like a few songs in one". Nonetheless, he called it an "irresistible take on Philadelphia soul" and praised it for being both "a camp commentary on the way people can dance in the face of crisis" and "catchy and amusing". Wren Graves, from online magazine
Consequence of Sound, listed "God Control" as one of the standout tracks in
Madame X; "Madonna's ambitions aren't merely musical. Several songs [on the album] contain social messages with varying amounts of bite ... But the message is even better expressed on the ambitious 'God Control'."
HuffPosts Daniel Welsh opined it was one of the album's "party tracks tinged with sadness". Robbie Barnett from the
Washington Blade compared it to Madonna's 2000 songs "
Music" and "
Impressive Instant", calling it "perfectly fit for dance floor consumption", the singer's best
dance track since "
Hung Up" (2005), as well as the best song on the album. In March 2023,
Billboard ranked "God Control" as Madonna's 89th greatest song, with Joe Lynch writing that "this unusual odyssey announced that Madonna was far from finished when it comes to taking risks and speaking her mind." == Music video ==