Economy Brewer identified as a
fiscal conservative during her political career. She became governor during the
Great Recession and spent her governorship reversing Arizona's deficit of about $3 billion. To do this, she reduced spending by $1 billion, borrowed $1 billion in funding, and passed a sales tax to raise $1 billion. Although she was successful in eliminating the state's deficit, it returned toward the end of her term. Opponents blamed her support for SB 1070, her veto of a religious rights bill, and her corporate tax cuts for dissuading businesses from investing in the state. Among other taxation policies, she enacted a tax cut for electric and natural gas companies, and she vetoed a bill in 2014 that would have expanded property tax exemptions for religious groups. After her governorship, Brewer opposed a 2021 bill that would have lowered income taxes with a permanent
flat tax.
Education Education was the issue that originally drew Brewer's interest to politics. She pushed for funding based on school performance based on a grading system, which her opponents said that this did not give enough funding to
schools in poor communities. As part of her spending cuts at the beginning of her governorship, Brewer reduced spending on
public schools by 2%. She vetoed any bills that would have made larger cuts to education spending. Brewer supported
school choice in the form of open enrollment while she was in the state legislature and supported
tax credits as governor so students can attend private schools, but she vetoed multiple
school voucher bills out of concern that they would unduly influence the market. Brewer signed HB 2881 on May 11, 2010, which withheld funding from any schools that taught resentment against a racial group or promoted the overthrow of the government. This was criticized as a means to attack
ethnic studies in general, but the only race-based instruction challenged by the law was a program to support Mexican American students in the
Tucson Unified School District. In response to right-wing criticism of the federal
Common Core curriculum, Brewer issued an executive order in 2013 saying that Arizona's school curriculum would be renamed to Arizona's College and Career Ready Standards. Although she said this was to retain state control over education, the same curriculum continued implementation.
Energy and environment in 2013 Brewer said in 2012 that she did not believe the scientific consensus that
global warming is man-made. She supported
nature conservation and provided funding for this while she was on the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors. Brewer reduced environmental regulations as governor. She created an Environmental Audit Privilege that allowed companies to not disclose environmental violations, and she granted mining companies greater leeway in natural resource extraction. She abolished the State Parks Heritage Fund and opposed the creation of a
Grand Canyon National Monument. Brewer opposed the federal
Endangered Species Act and supported an amendment to the Arizona Constitution that would guarantee the right to hunt, though she vetoed bills that threatened
Mexican wolf populations. She opposed a
Department of Homeland Security program that monitored the effect of a
Mexico–United States border wall on jaguar populations. She argued that the Western Climate Initiative's
cap-and-trade system would prevent economic recovery in Arizona. During the opening of a solar power plant in Phoenix, Brewer expressed support for a larger solar power industry in Arizona.
Gay rights Brewer objected to a federal court decision the same year that ruled Arizona's ban on same-sex marriage unconstitutional, which she considered an encroachment of judicial authority. Brewer supported
Arizona Proposition 107 as secretary of state in 2006, which would have defined marriage as between a man and a woman. She approved a budget that cut spousal benefits for domestic partners of government employees in 2009, reversing a policy implemented by Napolitano the previous year. In 2014, Brewer vetoed
SB 1062 which would have made it legal for businesses to refuse service to gay customers. She explained this by saying non-discrimination exists as a right alongside religious freedom, warning that its passage risked social division and "unintended consequences".
Government and legal Brewer opposed federal involvement in state politics. As governor, Brewer pushed for keeping Arizona military bases open, and vetoed a resolution in 2012, which declared that Arizona would fight any invading
United Nations forces. After Arizona's Child Protective Services was found to have shelved 6,500 abuse tips without investigation, Brewer abolished it and replaced it with a cabinet-level Division of Child Safety that answered to the governor directly in 2014. Brewer also created a Task Force on Human Trafficking in April 2013 and implemented its recommendations by creating the Arizona Human Trafficking Council in March 2014. She frequently rejected recommendations for
clemency, and she often did not provide a reason for commutations she granted. Her commutations were for typically for individuals who were near death or sentences that were "clearly excessive". Brewer vetoed a bill that would have expanded the death penalty out of concern that it would result in constitutional restrictions on capital punishment. Brewer campaigned on voting reform when she ran to be secretary of state for Arizona, and she implemented several changes while in office. She launched a program for members of the
United States Armed Forces deployed in other countries to vote through the internet or by fax machine. She had touch-screen voting made available for disabled voters, and to comply with federal law, she ended the use of
punch-card ballots. Brewer vetoed a bill on April 18, 2011, that would have required anyone running for president to have proof of U.S. citizenship. During Brewer's time as governor, she filled a number of vacancies in the courts. She appointed three State Supreme Court judges, Republicans
Ann Timmer,
John Pelander, and
Robert M. Brutinel. She also appointed a number of Superior and Appellate Court judges. Her opponents criticized her for promoting judges primarily from the Republican Party. She reformed state employment in 2012 so that any new government employees after September 28 were under
at-will employment. The bill also granted a temporary bonus for employees who switched to at-will employment. She argued that this would allow employees to be measured by merit instead of seniority and that it would make it easier to fire poorly-performing employees. Brewer announced the closure of the Arizona Department of Juvenile Corrections in January 2010 so its $67 million budget could be saved. Juvenile inmates would instead be sent to facilities operated by the counties. She argued that this would allow the inmates to be closer to their homes. The decision was opposed by most county governments and sheriffs, and it was unpopular among the general public. Following backlash, she rescheduled the closure date from July 2010 to July 2011 and appointed a committee to create a plan for disbanding the department, providing it to her in November 2010. She canceled her plan to close the department in December 2010 without providing a reason for her change of position.
Gun laws Brewer supported
gun rights as governor, and was endorsed by the
National Rifle Association in 2010. She signed the Firearms Freedom Act that exempted firearms and ammunition sold in Arizona from federal regulations if they were produced within the state, and she banned the destruction of guns that were legally seized or collected through
gun buyback programs. She also signed a bill that banned the use of zoning ordinances to limit the use of firearms on private property. Brewer expanded the right of
concealed carry, abolishing the requirement for a permit, legalizing concealed carry in places that serve alcohol unless they display a no weapons sign, and reducing the minimum age of concealed carry from 21 to 19 for military personnel. Brewer signed a bill declaring the
Colt revolver Arizona's official
state firearm, which was criticized for its passage shortly after the
2011 Tucson shooting and by Native American groups whose tribes were historically in conflict with people armed with the revolver. Despite her pro-gun stance, Brewer vetoed several laws supported by gun rights advocates. She vetoed bills legalizing the possession of a firearm in public buildings She also vetoed a bill that would have increased penalties on jurisdictions imposing gun laws that contradict state gun laws Though Brewer opposed the ACA, she deviated from her party by adopting the act's Medicaid expansion. She believed that taking the funding to support Arizona's poor was more pragmatic than rejecting it and letting the federal government allocate it elsewhere. Brewer oversaw an enrollment freeze for the KidsCare healthcare program amid a lack of funding, and she supported a proposition to end the children's health program First Things First. While she was in the state legislature, Brewer took on mental health as one of her main policy interests, spurred by her son's hospitalization for mental health reasons. Here she sponsored the first
living will law in the United States. When she became secretary of state, she negotiated a
public–private partnership that allowed advanced medical directives to be filed over the internet. As governor, Brewer cut funding for organ transplants in 2010 after the legislature determined that limited survival rates did not justify the cost. After criticism, the funding was restored. Brewer opposes abortion except for cases of rape and incest. Shortly after becoming governor, Brewer implemented a 24-hour waiting period for women seeking abortion. She signed an abortion bill that banned abortions on the basis of a fetus's race or sex in March 2011. The following year, she signed a ban on abortions after 20 weeks and an exemption to religious organizations to provide contraception in the healthcare coverage. Other abortion laws implemented by Brewer include a law forbidding minors from having an abortion unless they have written and notarized permission from their parents or guardians, a ban on state funding for abortion providers, and authorization of warrantless inspections of abortion clinics. She signed a ban on abortions after 20 weeks of pregnancy in April 2012, but it was struck down by the
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
Immigration galvanized both support and opposition on immigration policy. Immigration became the issue most closely associated with Brewer during her time as governor. She became a leading figure in immigration discourse, and her strong positions against illegal immigration made her incredibly popular within the Republican Party. Brewer signed
Arizona SB 1070 into law in 2010, causing national controversy. The bill made it a crime for non-citizens to be in Arizona without carrying paperwork that proves legal immigration or residency status. It also allowed law enforcement to ask about immigration status and required them to arrest anyone found to be in the United States illegally. Other provisions included restrictions on hiring undocumented immigrants and legalization of lawsuits against government agencies that prevent enforcement of immigration law. Brewer justified the policy by saying there were
drug traffickers among undocumented immigrants. Civil rights groups opposed the bill out of fear that it would encourage
racial profiling of Hispanic citizens. In response, Brewer created a program to train law enforcement when to ask about immigration status. While SB 1070 received national attention, Brewer signed several more immigration bills into law. These included bills that removed state recognition of consular cards as valid identification, retroactively applied a ban on undocumented immigrants claiming punitive damages in civil trials, made forgery a felony if it was done to establish a smuggling drop house, required that the state release children if the federal government issued a detainer, and required proof of legal status to obtain state identification. Before she was governor, Brewer was responsible for implementing
Arizona Proposition 200 as secretary of state in 2004, which required citizens in the state to show proof of citizenship before registering to vote or applying for public benefits. Critics of the proposition argued that it was anti-immigrant and discriminated against Latino citizens. ==See also==