Lyle and
Benny Gallagher initially teamed up in 1959 as members of a local
Largs-based band, The Bluefrets, and teamed up again in a band based in Saltcoats called the Tulsans with lead singer James (Drew) Galt, Dennis Donald (keyboards), Eric Brown on guitar, Benny Gallagher (bass) and Graham Lyle (drums). The Tulsans released two singles in 1965 under the name James Galt for
Pye that are now prized by
northern soul collectors: "Comes The Dawn" and "With My Baby". Benny and Graham later moved to London in the mid 60s. A rare one-off single, "Trees", was issued on UK
Polydor 56093 in 1967, under the name Gallagher-Lyle. In 1968, Gallagher and Lyle were signed by
Apple Records, where they wrote for musicians such as
Mary Hopkin ("Sparrow", "The Fields of St. Etienne", "International", "Heritage", and "Jefferson"). both of which also charted in the US. "Heart on My Sleeve" was subsequently covered by
Bryan Ferry,
Judith Durham and
Ringo Starr. Two other songs from this album were successful in the US:
Art Garfunkel's
cover of "Breakaway", topped the
Adult Contemporary chart, and
Don Williams took "
Stay Young" to No. 1 on the
Country record chart, which saw the song receive in excess of one million
airplays on American radio. The duo also penned and performed "A Heart in New York", which was later performed by both
Simon & Garfunkel and
Garth Brooks in their concerts in
Central Park, New York City, to audiences of 500,000 and 750,000, respectively. The pair's original recording of "A Heart in New York" eventually appeared on 1991's compilation album
Heart on My Sleeve – The Very Best of Gallagher and Lyle. As session musicians, Gallagher and Lyle also backed numerous big names on disc, including
Eric Clapton,
Andy Fairweather Low,
Gary Brooker and
Fairport Convention. The pair also had a stint in former
Faces member
Ronnie Lane's
folk rock band Slim Chance during 1973/74. Gallagher and Lyle split in 1980. ==Post-Gallagher and Lyle (1981–2009)==