There is some ambiguity about the extent of the range. Fenton Wyness, writing about Deeside, puts the northern edge of the Grampians at the River Dee in the introduction to his 1968 book
Royal Valley : The Story Of The Aberdeenshire Dee: This introduction appears to suggest that Wyness defines the Grampians as being the range of mountains running from immediately south of Aberdeen westward to
Beinn Dearg in the
Forest of Atholl. Similarly,
Adam Watson, when defining the extent of the
Cairngorms, specifically excluded the range south of the River Dee, writing: Both Wyness and Watson appear to exclude the Cairngorms from the Grampians, regarding them as a separate range. In effect, Wyness' and Watson's definition of the Grampians is as a
synonym for the
Mounth. However Robert Gordon, writing in the 1650s, used the term Grampians to refer to hills on either side of the River Dee, and thus explicitly included the Cairngorms within the range. Wyness and Watson both exclude areas west of the
Pass of Drumochter from the Grampians, but the 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica adopted a wider definition, including the highlands as far as
Dunbartonshire in the west. ==Geology==