Film review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes reports that 95% of critics gave the film a positive review based on 239 reviews; the average rating is 8.00/10. The site's consensus states: "Anchored by another tremendous performance in a career full of them,
All Is Lost offers a moving, eminently worthwhile testament to Robert Redford's ability to hold the screen." On
Metacritic the film has a score of 87 out of 100 based on 45 reviews, considered to be "universal acclaim". After the screening of the film at the Cannes Film Festival, Redford received a standing ovation. Writing for
The Independent, Geoffrey Macnab says the film was "utterly compelling viewing". Andrew Pulver, writing for
The Guardian, says that "Redford delivers a tour de force performance: holding the screen effortlessly with no acting support whatsoever."
Justin Chang of
Variety says of Redford's performance that he "holds the viewer's attention merely by wincing, scowling, troubleshooting and yelling the occasional expletive".
Robbie Collin of
The Telegraph says, "The film's scope is limited, but as far as it goes,
All Is Lost is very good indeed: a neat idea, very nimbly executed." In
The Guardian,
Peter Bradshaw raves: "Redford's near-mute performance as a mysterious old man of the sea adrift and utterly alone makes for a bold, gripping thriller." Spotting a possible metaphor, he observes: "... the entire drama works well as a parable of old age… the news of impending mortality pouring in through the windows like seawater" and concludes: "What a strikingly bold and thoughtful film." Alan Scherstuhl of
The Village Voice writes that the film is "a genuine nail-biter, scrupulously made and fully involving, elemental in its simplicity." David Morgan of
CBS News gives the film a positive review, stating, "Four decades ago Redford demonstrated a similar capacity for survival skills as the mountain man
Jeremiah Johnson. Today, at age 77, without a supporting cast and performing virtually all of his water stunts himself, Redford proves he is still up to the task, shining in what is an extremely physical but also an intellectually demanding role." However, the film has been criticized in the sailing world for being unrealistic, in particular for the lack of certain safety equipment deemed standard for sailboats navigating the open ocean, such as an
EPIRB, and other bad decisions made by the main character. An exception to this criticism is English
Yachting Monthly, in which Dick Durham claims: "Certainly the film is authentic and grippingly realistic." Director Chandor himself, who says he went sailing with his parents when young and later a few times as an adult, stated in an interview with German sailing magazine '''' that everything that happened in the film could have happened in reality. His only reservations were about the probability of crossing the Indian Ocean single-handed and the failure to evade the storm using modern technology and due attention.
Top ten lists All Is Lost was listed on many critics' top ten lists. • 2nd – Robert Horton,
Seattle Weekly • 3rd – Genevieve Koski,
The Dissolve • 3rd – Steve Davis,
Austin Chronicle • 3rd –
Ty Burr,
The Boston Globe • 3rd – Mark Savlov,
Austin Chronicle • 5th – Ann Hornaday,
The Washington Post • 5th – Mark Mohan,
The Oregonian • 5th –
Alonso Duralde,
TheWrap • 5th – Brian Miller,
Seattle Weekly • 6th – Stephen Schaefer,
Boston Herald • 6th –
Rex Reed,
The New York Observer • 6th – Marjorie Baumgarten,
Austin Chronicle • 6th –
Mike D'Angelo,
The A.V. Club • 6th – Noel Murray,
The Dissolve • 6th – Barbara Vancheri,
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette • 6th – Joshua Rothkopf,
Time Out New York • 6th –
A.O. Scott,
The New York Times • 7th –
David Edelstein,
Vulture • 7th – Scott Feinberg,
The Hollywood Reporter • 7th – Keith Phipps,
The Dissolve • 7th –
Sasha Stone, Awards Daily • 7th –
Christopher Orr,
The Atlantic • 7th – Kristopher Tapley,
HitFix • 8th –
Richard Roeper,
Chicago Sun-Times • 9th –
Lisa Schwarzbaum,
BBC • 9th – Chris Nashawaty,
Entertainment Weekly • 9th – Elizabeth Weitzman,
New York Daily News • Top 10 (listed alphabetically, not ranked) –
David Denby,
The New Yorker • Top 10 (listed alphabetically, not ranked) – James Verniere,
Boston Herald • Top 10 (listed alphabetically, not ranked) – Claudia Puig,
USA Today • Top 10 (listed alphabetically, not ranked) – Stephen Whitty,
The Star-Ledger • Top 10 (listed alphabetically, not ranked) –
Steven Rea,
The Philadelphia Inquirer ==Accolades==