Greatest Hits received mixed review upon release, with critics pointing out the challenge of summarising a lengthy career with only one album, including both notable omissions and the inclusion of four new tracks that had been cut from earlier albums. William Ruhlmann pointed out that the timing of the release (the day before the
Grammy Awards) was notable as "
Streets of Philadelphia" was up for five awards.
David Browne of
Entertainment Weekly referred to the liner notes when pointing out that some songs appeared to be "chosen for their chart success rather than for artistic merit" which means that several important songs were overlooked. He described the album as invigorating, but also felt that "Murder Incorporated" (a song about the 1930s
organized crime group of the same name) was the only good new song on the album and that overall the album felt as if Springsteen did not believe in himself any more. The
Rolling Stone review of the album by Parke Puterbaugh is rather unfavorable. Parke felt that the songs on the collection belonged on their original LP releases, that songs from before
Born to Run should have been included, and that the new songs weren't very good. == Commercial performance ==