The Group Theatre's first production was
Paul Green's
The House of Connelly on September 23, 1931, at the
Martin Beck Theatre. The company asked the
Theatre Guild to help cover the $5,000 cost to perform. The Theatre Guild offered to pay the full amount if the group "removed
Mary Morris and
Morris Carnovsky from the cast and restored the tragic ending" from the more upbeat and hopeful rewrite Green produced. The group's production of
John Howard Lawson's
Success Story, which chronicled the rise of a youthful idealist who sacrifices his principles as he rises to the top of the advertising business, received very mixed reviews, with
Luther Adler and
Stella Adler receiving the majority of the positive reviews. The group took on novelist
Dawn Powell's dark comedy
Big Night, rehearsed it for six months and asked for extensive revisions from the playwright. The result was a critical and box-office disaster that ran a scant nine performances. Harold Clurman, who took over the production late in the rehearsal period, later admitted the group's role in the fiasco. "The play should have been done in four swift weeks—or not at all. We worried it and harried our actors with it for months." Later, during the first full season (1933–34),
Men in White, written by
Sidney Kingsley, directed by Lee Strasberg and produced by
Sidney Harmon, became a financial success for the group. It won the
Pulitzer Prize for Drama. On the night of January 5, 1935, some members of the group participated in a benefit performance for the
New Theatre Magazine. Written by Clifford Odets and directed by Odets and Sanford Meisner, the one-act play
Waiting for Lefty was performed at the Civic Repertory Theatre in New York City and became a theatrical legend. The play reflects a kind of street poetry that brought great acclaim to the group and to Odets as the new voice of social drama in the 1930s. Odets became the playwright most strongly identified with the group, and its productions of
Awake and Sing! and
Paradise Lost, both directed in 1935 by Harold Clurman, proved to be excellent vehicles for the Stanislavskian aesthetic. The following year, the group produced the Paul Green-
Kurt Weill anti-war musical
Johnny Johnson, directed by Strasberg. The Group Theatre's most successful production was the 1937–38 Broadway hit
Golden Boy.
Elia Kazan directed
Robert Ardrey's plays
Casey Jones and
Thunder Rock in 1938 and 1939–40 for the Group Theatre. The group gathered at different summer locations to rehearse and train intensively for six of its 10 years in existence. The group spent the summer of 1931 at Brookfield Center, 1936 at
Pine Brook Country Club, located near
Nichols, Connecticut. Other summer venues included
Brookfield Center, Connecticut (1931); Dover Furnace in
Dutchess County, New York (1932); Green Mansions in
Warrensburg, New York in 1933; a large house in
Ellenville, New York (1934); and Lake Grove in
Smithtown, New York in 1939. Despite its success and sweeping impact on the American theater landscape for many years to come, the group ended by 1941, and factors included the impending war, the lure of fame and fortune in Hollywood, the lack of institutional funding, and the friction of interpersonal relationships. ==Broadway productions==