Peace with King Henry (1171–1188) In 1171 King Henry II arrived in England from France, on his way to Ireland. Henry wished to ensure that Richard de Clare, who had married Diarmait's daughter and become heir to Leinster, did not establish an independent Norman kingdom in Ireland. His decision to try a different approach in his dealings with the Welsh was influenced by the events in Ireland, although Warren suggests that "it seems likely that Henry began rethinking his attitude to the Welsh soon after the débâcle of 1165". Henry now wished to make peace with Rhys, who came to
Newnham to meet him. Rhys was to pay a tribute of 300 horses and 4,000 head of cattle, but was confirmed in possession of all the lands he had taken from Norman lords, including the Clares. They met again in October that year at
Pembroke as Henry waited to cross to Ireland. Rhys had collected 86 of the 300 horses, but Henry agreed to take only 36 of them and remitted the remainder of the tribute until after his return from Ireland. Rhys's son, Hywel, who had been held as a hostage for many years, was returned to him. Henry and Rhys met once more at
Laugharne as Henry returned from Ireland in 1172, and shortly afterwards Henry appointed Rhys "justice on his behalf in all Deheubarth". According to A. D. Carr: The agreement between Henry and Rhys was to last until Henry's death in 1189. When Henry's sons rebelled against him in 1173 Rhys sent his son Hywel Sais to Normandy to aid the king, then in 1174 personally led an army to
Tutbury in
Staffordshire to assist at the siege of the stronghold of the rebel Earl
William de Ferrers. When Rhys returned to Wales after the fall of Tutbury, he left a thousand men with the king for service in Normandy. King Henry held a council at
Gloucester in 1175 which was attended by a large gathering of Welsh princes, led by Rhys. It appears to have concluded with the swearing of a mutual assistance pact for the preservation of peace and order in Wales. In 1177 Rhys,
Dafydd ab Owain, who had emerged as the main power in Gwynedd, and
Cadwallon ap Madog from
Rhwng Gwy a Hafren swore fealty and liege homage to Henry at a council held at Oxford. At this council the king gave Meirionnydd, part of the kingdom of Gwynedd, to Rhys. Rhys built a number of stone castles, starting with
Cardigan Castle, which was the earliest-recorded native-built stone castle in Wales. He also built
Carreg Cennen Castle near Llandeilo, a castle set in a spectacular position on a mountain top. He held a
festival of poetry and song at his court at Cardigan over Christmas 1176. This is generally regarded as the first recorded
Eisteddfod. The festival was announced a year in advance throughout Wales and in
England,
Scotland,
Ireland and possibly
France. Two chairs were awarded as prizes, one for the best poem and the other for the best musical performance. J. E. Caerwyn Williams suggests that this event may be an adaptation of the similar French
puys. R.R. Davies suggests that the texts of
Welsh law, traditionally codified by
Hywel Dda at Whitland, were first assembled in book form under the aegis of Rhys. Rhys founded two religious houses during this period.
Talley Abbey was the first
Premonstratensian abbey in Wales, while Llanllyr was a
Cistercian nunnery, only the second nunnery to be founded in Wales and the first to prosper. He became the patron of the abbeys of
Whitland and
Strata Florida and made large grants to both houses.
Giraldus Cambrensis, who was related to Rhys, gives an account of his meetings with Rhys in 1188 when Giraldus accompanied Archbishop Baldwin around Wales to raise men for the
Third Crusade. Some Welsh clerics were not happy about this visit, but Rhys was enthusiastic and gave the Archbishop a great deal of assistance. Giraldus says that Rhys decided to go on crusade himself and spent several weeks making preparations, but was eventually persuaded to change his mind by his wife Gwenllian, "by female artifices".
Final campaigns (1189–1196) Henry II died in 1189 and was succeeded by
Richard I. Rhys considered that he was no longer bound by the agreement with King Henry and attacked the Norman lordships surrounding his territory. He ravaged
Pembroke,
Haverfordwest and
Gower, and captured the castles of St. Clear's,
Laugharne and
Llansteffan. Richard's brother, Prince John (later
King John), came to Wales in September and tried to make peace. He persuaded Rhys to raise the siege of
Carmarthen and accompany him to
Oxford to meet Richard. Rhys arrived at Oxford to discover that Richard was not prepared to travel there to meet him, and hostilities continued. In his later years Rhys had trouble keeping control of his sons, particularly
Maelgwn and
Gruffudd. In 1189 Gruffudd persuaded Rhys to imprison Maelgwn, and he was given into Gruffudd's keeping at Dinefwr. Gruffudd handed him over to his father-in-law,
William de Braose. Gruffudd is also said to have persuaded his father to annex the lordship of
Cemais and its chief castle of
Nevern, held by William
FitzMartin, in 1191. This action was criticised by
Giraldus Cambrensis, who describes Gruffudd as "a cunning and artful man". William FitzMartin was married to Rhys's daughter Angharad, and, according to Giraldus, Rhys "had solemnly sworn, by the most precious relics, that his indemnity and security should be faithfully maintained". Rhys had also annexed the Norman lordships of Cydweli and Carnwyllion in 1190. In 1192 Rhys secured Maelgwn's release, but by now Maelgwn and Gruffudd were bitter enemies. In 1194 Rhys was defeated in battle by Maelgwn and Hywel, who imprisoned him in
Nevern castle, though Hywel later released his father without Maelgwn's consent. Giraldus suggests that Rhys's incarceration in Nevern castle was divine vengeance for the dispossession of William
FitzMartin. In 1195 two other sons, Rhys Gryg and Maredudd, seized Llanymddyfri and Dinefwr, and Rhys responded by imprisoning them. Rhys launched his last campaign against the Normans in 1196. He captured a number of castles, including
Carmarthen,
Colwyn,
Radnor and
Painscastle, and defeated an army led by
Roger de Mortimer and Hugh de Say near
Radnor, with forty knights among the dead. This was Rhys' last battle. William de Braose offered terms, and Painscastle was returned to him.
Death and aftermath (1197) , having quarreled with the
Bishop of St Davids,
Peter de Leia, over the theft of some of the bishop's horses some years previously. Before he could be buried in the cathedral, the bishop had his corpse
scourged in posthumous penance. Rhys had nominated his eldest legitimate son, Gruffudd ap Rhys, as his successor, and soon after his father's death Gruffudd met the Justiciar, Archbishop
Hubert Walter, on the border and was confirmed as heir. Maelgwn, the eldest son but illegitimate, refused to accept this and was given military assistance by
Gwenwynwyn ab Owain of Powys. Maelgwn took the town and castle of
Aberystwyth and captured Gruffudd, whom he handed over to the custody of Gwenwynwyn. Gwenwynwyn later handed him over to the king, who imprisoned him at
Corfe Castle. There are no surviving
bardic elegies to Rhys, though the Peniarth 20 version of
Brut y Tywysogion contains a
Latin eulogy on his sepulchre: ==Character and historical assessment==