In 1956, Presnell co-starred with
Herva Nelli in the American premiere of
Darius Milhaud's opera
David at the
Hollywood Bowl. In 1960, he was a featured soloist with the
Los Angeles Philharmonic in another concert at the Bowl. In attendance at the concert was musical theater composer
Meredith Willson who was at that time in the midst of creating his musical on the life of
Molly Brown,
Titanic survivor. Willson contacted him after the concert and asked him to audition for him. Presnell complied and Willson ended up offering him the role of "Leadville Johnny." At this point the musical was not completed and Willson went on to compose much of the music for Leadville Johnny with Presnell's voice in mind. and Danny Churchill, the romantic lead, in the musical film
When the Boys Meet the Girls. He had one more sizable film role in the 1960s, the role of "Rotten Luck Willie" in Paramount's 1969 musical Western film
Paint Your Wagon, singing "
They Call the Wind Maria".
The New York Times critic opined that Presnell's role "delivered the golden opportunity to sing the unforgettable ballad." Referring to Eastwood and Marvin, film reviewer Brian W. Fairbanks wrote that "Harve Presnell steals both stars' thunder with a knockout version of the best song." Presnell did some other film and television work in the 1960s and early 1970s, but for the next couple of decades concentrated primarily on stage work, playing
Rhett Butler in the
West End production of
Scarlett and touring the United States as Daddy Warbucks in
Annie and its sequel,
Annie Warbucks, among other productions. In 1966, Presnell played the role of Sir Lancelot in
Camelot in the Regional Equity production at The Houston Music Theatre. In 1984, Presnell appeared as Don Quixote in
Man of La Mancha in
Darien, Connecticut, an appearance well received by
The New York Times critic
Alvin Klein, who wrote that Presnell was "a winning leading man", and wrote:As an actor, Mr. Presnell promises much, and as a singer, he delivers. Here is one of the shiniest vocal accounts of the role yet. The actor is on the verge of suggesting that in his implausible way, the Don can bring a measure of grace to the world and fulfill that old impossible dream. His film career was revived when he played
William H. Macy's testy father-in-law in
Fargo (1996). Subsequent films included
The Whole Wide World (1996),
Larger than Life (1996),
The Chamber (1996),
Face/Off (1997),
Julian Po (1997),
Saving Private Ryan (1998, as General
George C. Marshall),
Patch Adams (1998),
Walking Across Egypt (1999),
The Legend of Bagger Vance (2000),
The Family Man (2000),
Escanaba in da Moonlight (2001),
Mr. Deeds (2002),
Super Sucker (2003),
Flags of Our Fathers (2006), and
Evan Almighty (2007). On television, he appeared, in among other roles, as Mr. Parker on
The Pretender, Dr. Sam Lane on
Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman, and as A.I. Brooks on ''
Dawson's Creek''. ==Recordings==