Upon the film's release
The New York Times reported that "If the music of the Gershwin brothers can survive a terrible little musical such as "When the Boys Meet the Girls" [...] chances are it could outlast atomic annihilation," described the film overall as "a dull, silly scramble," and described the talents of Francis and Presnell as "strictly middling" and "teamed romantically, they look like Mutt and Jeff, and their vocal wrestling with the grand Gershwin melodies is slippery at best." A contemporary review in
Variety described the film as "a spotty comedy film, loaded with often extraneous tunes, also limited to some okay performances and gags," and reported that "Langdon remains the most impressive of the principals; she makes a first rate shrew." Writing for
Turner Classic Movies, critic Roger Fristoe described the film as "a very loose reworking of the George and Ira Gershwin musical
Girl Crazy," and noted that "the film allows for musical performances from an eclectic gathering of guest stars."
Filmink argued the movie was "it’a variety show grab bag, indicating MGM was unsure how to pitch the film. Presnell is not convincing in the lead, and Francis sings well but lacks energy – in her defence, she doesn’t really have a character to play. The film is bright and colourful at least." ==Awards==