The club played in the Kirkcaldy and District Amateur league until 1982 when they joined the
Fife Junior League. The Haws won the Fife League eight times before becoming founding members of the
East Region Super League in 2002. They spent all but one year in the Super League and finished runners-up three times, prior to their move to the East of Scotland League in 2018. A year later the club become full members of the
Scottish Football Association, allowing them to enter the Scottish Cup for the first time in
2019–20, and also joined the Fife FA which enables them to compete in the
Fife Cup. Hill of Beath Hawthorn's greatest honour came in 1990, when they defeated
Lesmahagow 1–0 in the final of the
Scottish Junior Cup at Kilmarnock's
Rugby Park. The club were managed by Jock Finlayson from their formation in 1975 until the summer of 2015 when he was succeeded by Bobby Wilson. On 14 May 2017, Bobby Wilson left the club by mutual consent. On 20 May 2017,
Kevin Fotheringham was named the new manager of the club. Kevin Fotheringham resigned as manager on 23 September 2019 after the Haws were knocked out the
Scottish Cup by
Gretna 2008. Former club captain, John Mitchell, was appointed as manager of the club on 16 October 2019. John Mitchell resigned in September 2021 In September 2021, the club appointed former professional footballer
Jason Dair as first-team manager. Dair, who made over 360 senior career appearances at clubs including Raith Rovers, Millwall, Dunfermline, Motherwell and Livingston, was joined by Lee Dair and Darrin Wright, both ex-Hill of Beath players, as first-team coaches, alongside Dave McNeely as goalkeeper coach. == Ground ==