Time magazine named "Hey There Delilah" one of The 10 Best Songs of 2007, ranking it number seven. Music critic
Josh Tyrangiel called it "an intimate love song that's damn near universal". Tyrangiel praised the Plain White T's for managing to make another "aching guy reaching out to distant girl song feel fresh", singling out singer Tom Higgenson's otherwise imperfect voice and "nasal delivery [for making] the nearly-comic sincerity of the lyrics seem completely genuine".
AllMusic positively compared the song to "
Thirteen" by
Big Star. The song was a double
2008 Grammy Award nominee, for
Song of the Year (won by
Amy Winehouse) and
Best Pop Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocal (won by
Maroon 5). DiCrescenzo attended the gala that year as the guest of Higgenson. On
VH1's Top 40 Videos of 2007, "Hey There Delilah" was number eight, ahead of "
If Everyone Cared" by
Nickelback and behind "
Say It Right" by
Nelly Furtado. VH1 had the song at number 78 on its list of the 100 Greatest Songs of the '00s. The band was featured on
Sesame Street in 2008 with the song "I'm the Letter T" (to the tune of "Hey There Delilah"). Higgenson provided the vocals for the animated letter
T who sings the spoof. When asked if he was excited, Higgenson responded, "Yeah, hello! It's a dream. But it's just my voice. There's going to be some Muppet singing it on the screen." In 2017, Jamie Milton of
NME said the track was one of the worst songs of the 2000s. She wrote: "It's earnest, self-indulgent pap of the highest order. This song is so wet that it's given me
swimmers' ear, which makes the narrator's self-regarding message – stand by myself while I take over the world with my forgettable, dreary acoustic guitar song – even more egregious." ==Personnel==