Duel with Davis Tutt , in an 1867 illustration accompanying the article by Nichols in ''
Harper's'' magazine While in Springfield, Hickok and a local gambler named
Davis Tutt had several disagreements over unpaid gambling debts and their common affection for the same women. Hickok lost a gold watch to Tutt in a poker game. The watch had great sentimental value to Hickok, so he asked Tutt not to wear it in public. They initially agreed not to fight over the watch, but Hickok saw Tutt wearing it and warned him to stay away. On July 21, 1865, the two men faced off in Springfield's town square, standing sideways before drawing and firing their weapons. Their quick-draw duel was recorded as the first of its kind. Tutt's shot missed, but Hickok's struck Tutt through the heart from about away. Tutt called out, "Boys, I'm killed" before he collapsed and died. Hickok was arrested for murder two days later, but the charge was reduced to manslaughter. He was released on $2,000 bail and stood trial on August 3, 1865. At the end of the trial, Judge
Sempronius H. Boyd told the jury that they could not find that Hickok acted in self-defense if he could have reasonably avoided the fight. However, if they felt that the threat of danger was real and imminent, he instructed that they could apply the unwritten law of the "fair fight" and acquit. The jury voted to clear Hickok, resulting in public backlash and criticism of the verdict.
Deputy U.S. marshal in Kansas In September 1865, Hickok came in second in the election for city marshal of Springfield, but he was recommended for the position of deputy federal marshal at
Fort Riley, Kansas. This was during the
Indian Wars, in which Hickok sometimes served as a scout for General
George A. Custer's
7th Cavalry. Witnesses confirm that Hickok was attacked by a large group of Indians on May 11, 1867 while working as a scout at
Fort Harker, Kansas. The Indians fled after he shot and killed two. In July, Hickok told a newspaper reporter that he had led several soldiers in pursuit of Indians who had killed four men near the fort on July 2. He reported returning with five prisoners after killing 10. Witnesses confirm that the story was true to the extent that the party had set out to find whoever had killed the four men, but the group returned to the fort "without nary a dead Indian" and without "even seeing a live one". On September 1, 1868, Hickok was in
Lincoln County, Kansas where he was hired as a scout by the
10th Cavalry Regiment, a segregated black unit. On September 4, Hickok was wounded in the foot while rescuing several cattlemen in the
Bijou Creek basin who had been surrounded by Indians. The 10th Regiment arrived at
Fort Lyon in
Colorado in October and remained there for the rest of 1868. Three sheriffs had quit during the previous 18 months. Hickok may have been acting sheriff before he was elected; a newspaper reported that he arrested offenders on August 18, and the commander of Fort Hays wrote a letter to the assistant
adjutant general on August 21 in which he praised Hickok for his work in apprehending deserters. The regular county election was held on November 2, 1869. Hickok ran as an Independent; but lost to his deputy, Peter Lanihan, who ran as a Democrat. Hickok and Lanihan, however, remained sheriff and deputy, respectively. Hickok accused a J.V. Macintosh of irregularities and misconduct during the election. On December 9, Hickok and Lanihan both served legal papers on Macintosh, and local newspapers acknowledged that Hickok had guardianship of Hays City.
Killings as sheriff Hickok killed two men in September 1869 during his first month as sheriff. The first was Bill Mulvey, who was galloping through town on a rampage, drunk, shooting out mirrors and whisky bottles behind bars. Citizens warned Mulvey to behave because Hickok was sheriff, but Mulvey angrily declared that he had come to town to kill Hickok. When he saw Hickok, he leveled his cocked rifle at him. Hickok waved his hand past Mulvey at some supposed onlookers and yelled, "Don't shoot him in the back; he is drunk." Mulvey wheeled his horse around to face those who might shoot him from behind, and Hickok shot him through the temple before he realized that he had been fooled. The second man killed by Hickok was Samuel Strawhun, a cowboy who was causing a disturbance in a saloon at 1:00 a.m. on September 27 when Hickok and Lanihan went to the scene.
Marshal of Abilene, Kansas , a well-known gunfighter, claimed to have killed at least 27 men. In his autobiography, Hardin made the unlikely claim that he had once disarmed Town Marshal "Wild Bill" Hickok with the use of the "
road agent's spin" while surrendering his guns to the lawman due to a local ordinance. On April 15, 1871, Hickok became marshal of
Abilene, Kansas after being hired by mayor Joseph McCoy, who had won the mayoral election that same month. He replaced
Tom "Bear River" Smith, who had been killed while serving an arrest warrant on November 2, 1870. Outlaw
John Wesley Hardin arrived in Abilene at the end of a cattle drive in early 1871. Hardin was a well-known gunfighter, and is known to have killed more than 27 men. Hardin claimed in his 1895 autobiography that he was befriended by Hickok, the newly elected town marshal, after he had disarmed the marshal using the
road agent's spin, but Hardin was known to exaggerate. In any case, Hardin appeared to have thought highly of Hickok. In August 1871, Hickok sought to arrest Hardin for killing Charles Couger in an Abilene hotel "for snoring too loud", but Hardin left Kansas before Hickok could arrest him. A newspaper reported, "A man was killed in his bed at a hotel in Abilene, Monday night, by a desperado called Arkansas. The murderer escaped. This was his sixth murder."
Shootout with Phil Coe Hickok had a dispute with saloon owner
Phil Coe that resulted in a shootout. Coe had established the Bull's Head Saloon in Abilene in partnership with gambler
Ben Thompson. The two men had painted a picture of a bull with a large erect penis on the side of their establishment as an advertisement. Citizens of the town complained to Hickok, who requested that Thompson and Coe remove the image. They refused, so Hickok altered it himself. Infuriated, Thompson tried to incite John Wesley Hardin to kill Hickok by exclaiming to Hardin that "he's a damn Yankee. Picks on rebels, especially Texans, to kill." Hardin was in town under his assumed name Wesley Clemmons, but was better known to the townspeople by the alias "Little Arkansas". He seemed to have respect for Hickok's abilities and replied, "If Bill needs killing, why don't you kill him yourself?" Hickok was relieved of his duties as marshal less than two months after the accidental shooting, this incident being only one of a series of questionable shootings and claims of misconduct during his career. ==Later life==