The stadium, a large concrete oval with near-continuous seating laid out like a classical amphitheater, was inspired by a decade-long popular "stadium movement" in the 1920s, and was finally brought to fruition through the persistent efforts of its namesake Mayor John Hinchliffe, who made his fortune from
Hinchliffe Brewing before it closed due to
Prohibition. It opened on July 8, 1932, as a combination athletic facility and a "paying investment" for the working people of industrial Paterson, New Jersey, who were by then struggling through the early years of the
Great Depression. Many workers laid off from the mills found work under a
New Deal-financed program to provide enhancements to the stadium in 1932–34. The stadium immediately played host to the
Negro National League and "barnstorming" games. In 1933, the stadium's first complete season hosting baseball, Hinchliffe hosted the Colored Championship of the Nation, the
Negro leagues equivalent of the World Series, between the
New York Black Yankees and
Philadelphia Stars. That same year, the
New York Black Yankees made the stadium their home, a tenure that lasted until 1938 and was interrupted only once in the 1936 season when they split time between
Freeport and
Middletown, New York. After 1939, the Black Yankees left Hinchliffe and took up residency at
Yankee Stadium in the
Bronx, New York. Hinchliffe was also home to the
New York Cubans in 1935 and 1936. Hinchliffe Stadium hosted high-level baseball games featuring many prominent athletes. Players who competed there included athletes like
Monte Irvin,
Josh Gibson,
Oscar Charleston, and
"Cool Papa" Bell. Hall-of-Famer
Larry Doby, who broke the American League color barrier in 1947, grew up in Paterson playing football and baseball in Hinchliffe Stadium for Paterson's
Eastside High School, and was scouted from Hinchliffe for the
Newark Eagles in 1942. Hinchliffe became an important venue for
boxing (Diamond Gloves, precursor to the Golden Gloves),
auto racing (precursor to
NASCAR featuring stock car racing, pre-Indianapolis racing, and
midget car racing events), and professional football. Racers who appeared at Hinchliffe included
Dutch Schaefer,
Ted Horn,
Bill Schindler,
Art Cross, and Tex Keene.
Victory Bond rallies held at the stadium during
World War II drew sports stars and New York and Hollywood celebrities by the dozens. Among the many notable events headlined at Hinchliffe were comedy shows performed by
Abbott and Costello. (Costello was born and raised in Paterson's Eastside section.) Throughout its history, though, Hinchliffe Stadium's primary use was as a venue for Paterson high school sports. Its two high schools, Eastside High School and Central High School, shared the stadium for various sports including football and baseball until the late 1960s. (
Kennedy High School, opened in 1965, also used Hinchliffe.) The schools' annual intracity
Thanksgiving Day matchup was always held at Hinchliffe (that tradition would return when the stadium officially reopened in 2023), and the venue would also play host to other local schools' teams to take advantage of its larger capacity; for instance, Paterson's neighbor
Clifton used the stadium for football during the 1940s until opening its own stadium October 14, 1950. == Later years, closing and preservation efforts ==