Since its initial release,
The Marshall Mathers LP has been highly acclaimed in retrospective critic reviews. It has been regarded by critics as Eminem's best album and has been ranked in multiple lists of the greatest albums of all time. In
The Rolling Stone Album Guide (2004), Christian Hoard said it "delved much deeper into personal pain [than
The Slim Shady LP], and the result was a minor masterpiece that merged iller-than-
ill flows with a brilliant sense of the
macabre." According to Sputnikmusic's Nick Butler,
The Marshall Mathers LP stands as a culturally significant record in American popular music, but also "remains a truly special album, unique in rap's canon, owing its spirit to rock and its heritage to rap, in a way I've rarely heard". Insanul Ahmed of
Complex wrote, "At a time when the
Billboard charts were dominated by squeaky-clean pop acts like
NSYNC and
Backstreet Boys, Eminem offered a rebuttal to the hypocritical American mainstream that criticizes rap music while celebrating—and, worse, commercializing—sex, violence, and bigotry in other arenas. This album turned Eminem into a global icon. There was a huge amount of hype and controversy around it [...] But none of that takes away from its musical achievement. This album definitively proved that the Detroit rapper was a gifted lyricist, a brilliant songwriter, and a visionary artist." Jeff Weiss of
The Ringer wrote,
"The Marshall Mathers LP certified Eminem as an alienated voice of a generation, a caustic wedge issue distilling the spirits of
Elvis,
Holden Caulfield,
Johnny Rotten,
Kurt Cobain,
Cartman from
South Park, and
Tupac if he shopped at
Kroger. In a postmodern abyss where everything's performative, it might have been the last album that possessed the capacity to genuinely shock." Dan Ozzi of
Vice highlighted that "Eminem was the one artist high school kids seemed to unanimously connect with. [...] he represented everything high school years are about: blind rage, misguided rebellion, adolescent frustration. He was like a human middle finger. An X-rated
Dennis the Menace for a dial-up modem generation." Max Bell of
Spin wrote that the album remains "one of the most critically-acclaimed, commercially-successful, and influential albums in rap history", citing rappers influenced by the album, such as
Tyler, the Creator,
Earl Sweatshirt,
Kendrick Lamar, and
Juice WRLD. Bonsu Thompson of
Medium described the album as "a masterful confluence of
punk,
bluegrass, and subterranean hip-hop that gave life to a singular brand of Americana rap." it was moved up to number 244 in the magazine's revised 2012 edition of the list, and moved to 145 on the 2020 edition.
IGN named it the twenty-fourth greatest rap album of all time in a 2004 list. In 2006,
The Marshall Mathers LP was included by
Time in its list of the 100 Greatest Albums of All Time. That same year,
Q ranked it number 85 on a list of The Greatest Albums of All Time, the highest position held by any hip-hop album on the list.
The Marshall Mathers LP was also the highest ranked hip-hop album on the
National Association of Recording Merchandisers & the
Rock and Roll Hall of Fame's list of the 200 Definitive Albums of All Time, where it was placed at number 28. It has been named one of the Top 100 Albums of the Decade (2000s) by
Rolling Stone, who ranked it seventh,
Complex Magazine, who ranked it fourth, and
Pitchfork, who ranked it 119th.
The Guardian ranked the album at 29 on its Top 50 Albums of the decade.
The A.V. Club ranked the album at 36 on its Best Albums of the Decade list.
Popdose listed
The Marshall Mathers LP as the 10th best album of the decade.
Spinner ranked the album at 22 on its Best Albums of the 2000s list. In 2010,
Rhapsody ranked it at number 1 on their list of "The 10 Best Albums by White Rappers". In 2015, the album was ranked number 81 by
About.com on their list of 100 Best Hip-Hop Albums of All Time. In 2020,
The Marshall Mathers LP was included at the 100 Best Albums of the 21st Century list of
Stacker, being ranked at 69. The album was also included in the book
1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. In 2022, it was ranked 25 by
Rolling Stone on their list "The 200 Greatest Rap Albums of All Time". In a 2024 ranking of Eminem's 12 studio albums, Damien Scott of
Billboard magazine placed
The Marshall Mathers LP first, concluding: "It's the definitive Eminem album, the one by which all others are measured. If you've never listened to Eminem and are looking for a place to start, begin with this." == Controversies ==