Daily's performance that season caught the eye of Major League teams, and he signed with the
Buffalo Bisons for the 1882 season. Although he shared starts with future
Hall of Famer Pud Galvin, he was able to pitch in 29 games, winning 15 of them. He finished the season with a 23–19 win–loss record, and finished in the top ten in several pitching categories. He finished second in the league with two
shutouts, fifth place with a 2.42 earned run average, seventh in strikeouts with 171, and ninth in the league in wins, games pitched, and games started. – a remarkable total, given that in 1882 and 1883 walks were issued after seven
balls rather than four. For the 1884 season, he feasted on the upstart Union Association's lack of talent, pitching for the
Chicago Browns (which became the Pittsburgh Stogies), and for the
Washington Nationals later in the season. He finished with a 28–28 win–loss record, but did have a low 2.43 ERA, Among the season totals, he struck out
19 batters in a game, on 7 July, tying
Charlie Sweeney. Unofficially, his reported 19 strikeout game was upgraded to 20 when it was discovered that one batter had struck out but reached first base when the pitch got away from the
catcher. This meant that Daily did not just tie the record, but broke it instead (
Roger Clemens then unofficially tied the mark in 1986 two of them back to back, which was also itself a record at the time. The record was later matched by
Grover Cleveland Alexander in 1915. He joined the
St. Louis Maroons of the National League, where he only pitched in 11 games, and had a record of 3 wins and 8 losses. The rest of his career included short stints with the 1886
Washington Nationals, and the 1887
Cleveland Blues of the American Association. He played his final major league game on 21 August 1887. ==Later life==