Battles Without Honor and Humanity was a box office success and made Sugawara a star and Fukasaku an A-list director. The first installment earned its distributor $4.5 million at the box office, making it the eleventh highest-grossing film of the year. The second and third films ranked twelfth and thirteenth for the same year, respectively, while the last two both ranked in the top ten of 1974. On
Kinema Junpos annual list of the best films for the year of 1973 as voted by critics, the first film placed second,
Proxy War placed eighth and
Deadly Fight in Hiroshima thirteenth. In 2009, the magazine named it fifth on an aggregated list of the Top 10 Japanese Films of All Time as voted by over one hundred film critics and writers. Previous editions of the list had the series at number twenty-two in 1995 and eighth in 1999, tied with
Twenty-Four Eyes. In 2011,
Complex named it number one on their list of The 25 Best Yakuza Movies. Yamane believes
Battles Without Honor and Humanity was popular because of the time of its release; Japan's economic growth was at its peak and at the end of the 1960s
the student uprisings took place. The young people had similar feelings to those of the post-war society depicted in the films. The Fukasaku biographer and film expert also stated that for the rest of his career Fukasaku was approached many times by producers to create movies similar to
Battles, but always turned them down wanting to move on to films he found interesting.
Mark Schilling wrote that many Japanese commentators cite the films' extensive use of the Hiroshima
dialect as fresh, because it was not heard in many mainstream films at the time. Prior, movies about yakuza were known as
ninkyō eiga or "
chivalry films" and set in pre-war Japan.
The A.V. Club's Noel Murray states that Fukasaku's yakuza instead only "adhere to codes of honor when it's in their best interest, but otherwise bully and kill indiscriminately." Dennis Lim of
The Village Voice writes "Fukasaku's yakuza flicks drain criminal netherworlds of romance, crush codes of honor underfoot, and nullify distinctions between good and evil."
DVD Talk's
Glenn Erickson called
Battles Without Honor and Humanity a "violent saga awash in blood, betrayal, treachery and aggression". Describing the first two films as following Hirono as he forms ties with doomed friends who try to live up to the yakuza code, giving viewers something to care about in "what would otherwise be a completely nihilistic series of rotten deals and betrayals", Erickson wrote that by the third film Fukasaku and his writers veer into political territory; he interpreted the yakuza captains using their underlings as proxies in their fights as an allegory for what America and the Soviet Union did in the
Cold War. Kyle Anderson of the
Nerdist referred to the series as "the fastest, most frenetic, least apologetic gangster pictures ever made." He noted how the onscreen text giving the victim's name and date of death after each murder, coupled with the handheld photography, give the films a "newsreel style that draws the viewer in." ==Sequels==