The Dreamcast version received favorable reviews, while the Nintendo 64 and PlayStation versions received mixed or average reviews, according to the
review aggregation website
GameRankings. Six issues later, however, Lamchop said of the Nintendo 64 version, "Like the
Titanic,
Hydro Thunder takes to the water well-equipped, but slow gameplay is the iceberg that sinks it. You may still want to rent
HT to test the waters, but consider yourself warned." An issue later, Jake The Snake said of the PlayStation version, "If you like arcade-style racers and want a break from automobiles, don't miss the boat on
Hydro Thunder." Cam Shea of
Hyper gave the Dreamcast version 84% in its January 2000 issue, saying, "After playing the arcade version, it has to be said that
Hydro Thunder is a very faithful port. Graphically this is a good thing, but in terms of replay value, the Dreamcast version suffers for its arcade heritage. It may come packing all the graphics, boats and courses, but it's very much a no frills port that ultimately has a similar replay value to the original." Five issues later, however, Arthur Adam gave the Nintendo 64 version 72%, saying that it "doesn't give the impression of speed to make it a worthwhile racer, feeling more like a gentle ride up an escalator being powered by monkeys pulling a rope."
Edge gave the Dreamcast version six out of ten, calling it "mad nautical gaming – aggressive, surreal and compulsive. Sometimes shallow, it is not
Mario Kart on water, more a damp
Driver – full of noticeable flaws, but a lot of fun." ==Legacy==