"I Could Fall in Love" dominated the Top 40 radio stations, a fact that was well received by critics. The song was given
heavy rotation in the southern United States, becoming the most played song in
Kansas City,
Miami, and
Boston and the second most played in
Los Angeles. In
Tucson, Arizona, it was played every 2½ hours, and in
San Antonio every hour. The song was played 25 times its first day of availability on US radios on the Harlingen, Texas radio station
KBTQ. It helped increase Selena's catalogue sales and simultaneously boosted media attention. In
Riverside, California, program directors reported that "I Could Fall in Love" was one of the three hits they were playing most often on their radio stations. A San Antonio disc jockey told
The Victoria Advocate about the overwhelming response received from the English-speaking audience, who were constantly calling her radio station asking for "I Could Fall in Love". "Dreaming of You" and "I Could Fall in Love" were EMI Records' top selling
digital downloads from 1 April 2004 to 31 March 2005. "I Could Fall in Love" became one of Selena's most widely recognized recordings. Amanda Edwards of Voxxi.com called it "one of the most popular Latin love songs of all time", adding that, "from her sweet voice to the genuine sentiment of the song (with a hint of sexiness if you're listening carefully), we're sold on this track being a solid standby any time of year but especially for someone hoping for romance on Valentine's Day".
Covers A number of singers have adapted the song in a variety of genres. Puerto Rican-American singer and actress
Jennifer Lopez lip-synced the track for her portrayal of the title role in the 1997 biographical film
Selena, which was praised by critics. Reviewing the film's opening, a
Wichita Eagle writer described the song as "hauntingly lovely" and said that it expressed the feelings of Selena's fans. Lopez included "I Could Fall in Love" in the
set list for her
Let's Get Loud Tour in 2001 at the
Roberto Clemente Coliseum in
San Juan, Puerto Rico, and on 11 February 2003 she included the song in her live video album ''
Jennifer Lopez: Let's Get Loud. Cuban singer Gloria Estefan performed a cover version during the Selena ¡VIVE! concert in 2005; Tarradell commented in The Dallas Morning News
that it had been a "lovely rendition". Puerto Rican singer Ana recorded the song for her album Amor Latino''. The Korean singer Im Tae Kyung performed a slower pop ballad version that incorporates a guitar as its musical foundation. A reggae-inspired version of the song appeared on Fiona's
Best of Sweet Love.
Season three American Idol contestant
Lisa Leuschner included the song in her album
Reality. In
Kumbia Kings' third compilation album
Duetos (2005), Selena's brother A.B. Quintanilla III recorded "I Could Fall in Love" as a Spanglish duet with Selena. For the album
Familia RMM Recordando a Selena, recorded by various artists in 1996,
Los Jovenes Del Barrio performed a cover of the song.
Season 10 American Idol contestant
Karen Rodriguez performed "I Could Fall in Love" during the "top 13" episode, receiving unfavorable reviews from critics who considered the song too powerful for her. However,
The Washington Post contributor Derrik Lang called Rodriguez' cover a "breathy redemption".
American Idol alumna
Katie Stevens wrote to
The Hollywood Reporter, claiming that the judges on the show had judged Rodriguez too harshly and calling Rodriguez the "new Selena". Rodriguez recorded a studio version of "I Could Fall in Love" in 2011 for her debut album, which was produced by
Jim Jonsin.
Solange Knowles included the song in the set list for her 2013 world tour, which has received praise from music critics. Joey Guerra of the
Houston Chronicle wrote that Knowles had "put a lovely, downtempo twist on 'I Could Fall in Love". Michael O'Connell of
The Hollywood Reporter called Knowles' rendition a "fangirl cover". Writing in the
San Francisco Weekly, Erin Browner considered Knowles' cover the "highlight of the night" when she performed it at the start of her US tour. Browner commented that the "combination of sexy Solange and Selena's epic love song was almost too much for the audience to handle" and that "people immediately whipped out their phones to record (yep, it's already on YouTube) and/or just plain cried the lyrics along with her". On 29 March 2015, Filipino singers
Angeline Quinto,
Yeng Constantino, and
Juris Fernandez performed "I Could Fall in Love" for the variety show
ASAP. American singer
Adrienne Bailon performed "I Could Fall in Love" after a six-year departure from the music business, during 31 March 2015 episode of
The Real; a talk show she co-hosted from 2013 to 2022. == Formats and track listings ==