"Lighters" received mixed reviews by most
music critics. Most of them commented on the different style of the song when compared to other songs on
Hell: The Sequel, Markman had a positive opinion regarding "Lighters". He wasn't surprised to hear Eminem's performance, "It's hard to imagine a time when Eminem wasn't regarded as one of rap's elite". Not only did he comment on Royce da 5'9"s verse, "The gritty Detroit MC recalls his own battles to the top, referencing doubters at every turn", but also noticed that the track was "inspirational", addictive and made to be sent to the radio.
About.com's Bill Lamb gave a generally positive review, awarding the song four out of five stars, naming it "an engaging, soulful pop hip hop blend", by having humorous lyrics and "Mars' soulful, memorable rap", but went on to mention that the track "sounds a bit schmaltzy at times." The recording's chorus was praised by Nathan Rabin of
The A.V. Club. Rabin also added that it wouldn't give a "welcome relief from the claustrophobic darkness of the rest of the album." In a mixed review,
Billboard editor Jason Lipshutz published a track-by-track review of each song on the album. He thought that the single did not fit in with the rest of
Hell: The Sequel, but alone, is a good song, "[The] track doesn't fit with EP, but Em's effortless confidence carries the celebratory anthem." Chad Grischow of
IGN gave a shared a similar opinion, calling the song odd and uncommon. Grischow did not favor the influences of "gooey synthpop" and
soul fusion genres. While exploring the
Billboard charts on their segment at
The A.V. Club, writers Genevieve Koski and Steven Hyden, commented on "Lighters". Koski said that the single shared some similarities with "Nothin' on You", which also featured Mars. Despite noticing the contrast between the rap verses and the hook, she focused her attention on the various elements of the recording which "are each uplifting in their own way" and awarded it a B−. On the other hand, Hyden gave the song a harsh critic calling it the, "absolute worst in pop music right now". He criticized Eminem for spitting in his verses, Mars for singing a "melodramatic chorus" and the type of music the rapper, Eminem, was embracing dubbing it, "maudlin power balladry". He gave the record an F. In a negative review, David Jeffries of
Allmusic said that "the glossy 'Lighters' feels more like a Bruno Mars track than Detroit diesel."
Consequence of Sound reviewer Winston Robbins gave a rather negative review on "Lighters". Robbins believes that Mars's vocal delivery in the chorus does not fit into a rap song and would have done better on a solo record or with another artist. David Amidon from music website
PopMatters said that "Lighters" was the only disappointing recording of the 11 tracks on the EP deluxe edition and "it's easy to press the skip button if you’d like to." At the 2012
ASCAP Pop Music Awards it was one of the winners of Most Performed Songs. ==Commercial performance==