Elizabeth Rosenthal, author of
His Song: The Musical Journey of Elton John, considers
Ice on Fire to be John's "first genuine soul album of the 1980s." Jeff Giles of
Ultimate Classic Rock characterizes John's sound at the time of the album as a "mechanized strain of soul and R&B", while
AllMusic's
Stephen Thomas Erlewine describes the album's aesthetic as "pure 1985, heavy on synthetic drums and keyboards". Rosenthal also notes a "huskiness" to John's voice throughout the album, an early sign of the vocal issues that would result in John's 1987 surgery. The album opens with "This Town", a commentary on the decline of the United States'
Rust Belt. The lyrics' "images of despair" are juxtaposed against upbeat music which includes a horn section as well as vocal exchanges between John and Sister Sledge displaying elements of
gospel music. "Cry to Heaven" takes place in an unidentified war-torn area, and reflects the hopelessness felt by the innocent citizens affected by the conflict. Conversely, "Soul Glove" is an upbeat love song, using the metaphor of a "tight-fitting glove" to demonstrate the compatibility of the two partners. As implied by the title, the song exhibits a strong soul music influence, with a prominent horn section. "Nikita", the album's best-known song, is a
ballad Judy Parkinson, author of
Elton: Made in England (2003), calls the track "an evocative love song to a lonely East European girl". Rosenthal likens the song to John's earlier song "
Daniel" (1973), and also cites it as another example of John's "huskier" voice and increased use of a lower register on the album. that despite being known primarily as a female name in the US, Nikita is a traditionally male name in Russia. The album's first side closes with "Too Young", narrated by a man in love with a woman whose parents disapprove of the relationship, due to their age gap. John likened the song to
1960s torch songs in the vein of
the Righteous Brothers. Included on the original CD and cassette is "Act of War", a duet with
Millie Jackson. Jeff Giles of
Ultimate Classic Rock considers the track to be "one of Elton's more musically aggressive" songs from the 1980s, while also noting the appearance of the soul and R&B influences present on the album proper. Rosenthal considers the track to be an update of John's earlier "Hard Luck Story" (from
Rock of the Westies (1975)), depicting a conflict between a married couple. Musically, the track features "aggressive" guitar and a "percussive, minimalist" melody. ==Release and reception==