The novel is based on Cooper's short story
The Holiday Makers, which was first published in the magazine
19. Upon publication
The Bookseller described the novel as "clever stuff" with its intended audience a "semi-sophisticated" readership.
The Observer described the novel as "puns-and needles" and stated that Cooper's writing "improved with every book". The following year,
The Bookseller described the novel as the sixth in the
romance series by Cooper, noting that the first five had sold over 340,000 copies. Later the same year,
The Wokingham Times described Imogen as Cooper's "most spineless heroine" and suggested that readers only buy one of Cooper's books as the jokes are so similar across them. In contrast
The Bolton News was sympathetic to the title character and described the novel as dealing with Imogen's "crisis of conscience in the face of a materialistic society" with "subtlety and delicacy". Writing in 2011 in a piece about namesakes in literature, Imogen Russell Williams described how she was disappointed when she read the work, in that the character of Imogen was not transformed by love, and is the same "shy, virginal, and girlishly freckled" woman at the end. In a 2018 review of Cooper's works, Sarah Manning described how, as a younger reader, Imogen's seduction by someone "
caddish" felt thrilling. She also described Imogen's character as "awkward". In 2023 Irish journalist
Emily Hourican stated she'd choose
Imogen and the other novels in Cooper's romance series as her specialist subject on
Mastermind. == Analysis ==