Critical reception Many critics responded very positively to
Inside No. 9. The overall series has a 100% score at Rotten Tomatoes. Commentators have described it as "never less-than-captivating"
Inside No. 9 won the Sketch and Comedy prize at the 35th annual
Banff World Media Festival Rockie Awards, and won the comedy prize at the 2016
Rose d'Or ceremony. It was nominated for the Best TV Sitcom prize at the 2014
Freesat Awards, the
Broadcast Award for Best Original Programme, and at the 2014
British Comedy Awards for both the Best New Comedy Programme and the Best Comedy Drama. In the
Comedy.co.uk Awards it was voted "Best TV Comedy Drama" in 2014, 2015, 2016, and 2017, and was named "Comedy of the Year" in 2017 and 2018. The series has received three nominations at the
British Academy Television Awards. In 2019, Pemberton won
Best Male Comedy Performance. In 2021, Shearsmith was nominated for the same award and the show won
Best Scripted Comedy. After the final episode of the first series, the comedic critic
Bruce Dessau said on his website that it had "really set an early benchmark to beat for comedy of the year. It has been consistently compelling as each week we entered an entirely different world." Chater had previously described "A Quiet Night In", the second episode of
Inside No. 9, as "the funniest, cleverest, most imaginative and original television I have seen for as long as I can remember – one of those fabulous programmes where time stands still and the world around you disappears". Mark Jones (
The Guardian) considered the whole series, saying that the
Inside No. 9 was "never less-than-captivating", while a review in the
Liverpool Echo described every episode as "intriguing and lovingly-crafted", though it was felt that the first three episodes were stronger than the latter three. In December 2014,
Metro television critic Keith Watson named
Inside No. 9 the twentieth best television programme of 2014, and in January 2015,
Daily Star Sunday columnist
Garry Bushell named
Inside No. 9 the best comedy TV programme of 2014. Writing before
Inside No. 9 was televised, broadcaster and journalist
Mark Lawson suggested that, among anthology series, the programme possessed "the potential to be remembered as a singular achievement". Also writing mid-series, journalist Gareth Lightfoot called
Inside No. 9 "hands down the best, freshest thing on [television] at the moment" in the
Evening Gazette, though he doubted whether it could truly be considered comedy. Donal Lynch, of Irish newspaper the
Sunday Independent, suggested that, like the previous work of Pemberton and Shearsmith,
Inside No. 9 may be something of "a cult hit/acquired taste". Barry Didcock, of
The Herald, expressed a similar sentiment, calling
Inside No. 9 "probably the most Marmitey programme on television".
The Times published a response to a complaint received from a viewer, who was unhappy with Chater's positive reviews of
Inside No. 9, suggesting that "A Quiet Night In" was more traumatic than humorous. Sam Wollaston, television critic for
The Guardian, noted that humour is extremely personal, and though he could appreciate much about
Inside No. 9, he had never liked Pemberton and Shearsmith's work: "I'm sure I'll be crucified – probably quite rightly – but I don't love
Inside No 9." Some tabloid columnists also expressed dissatisfaction with the programme. Virginia Blackburn, of the
Daily Express, wrote a highly critical review of "Last Gasp". Blackburn considered
Inside No. 9 an example of the weakness of contemporary television comedy, saying that the episode is "not funny, it's not clever and is so utterly, irredeemably, naffly silly that it ends up being incredibly irritating and nothing else". Another journalist unimpressed was the
Daily Mirror columnist Kevin O'Sullivan, who dismissed the programme by saying simply "BBC2's alleged comedy
Inside No. 9: didn't even smile". Cooke observed the difficulty in reviewing
Inside No. 9 as a whole due to the fact that each episode is different from the last. as well as the scripting, but it was well received as funny, and inventive. "Tom & Gerri" was less comedic but darker than previous episodes; critics commended the plot, but disagreed about the portrayal of
mental illness in the episode. and was considered a weaker instalment. Critics called "The Understudy" a "return to form". While it was based upon
Macbeth, a knowledge of the play was not necessary for enjoyment, and the plot's divergence from the play was praised. "The Harrowing" was the most horrific episode of the series, and was considered genuinely scary by critics. "La Couchette" was characterised by critics as strong and funny, with praise directed at the cast and script. "The 12 Days of Christine" was hailed as "masterpiece" and "a quiet elegy, terse and polished, in many ways perfect". The emotional script, poignancy of the ending and performance of the cast, especially Smith, was highly praised. "The Trial of Elizabeth Gadge" was compared unfavourably with the previous two episodes by some critics, though the writers were characterised as having displayed their versatility and ability with the atypical setting and language. Critics had a mixed response to the episode's humour, "Cold Comfort" was generally praised, though also characterised as weaker than other episodes in the series. but there was a mixed response to the episode's ending. "Nana's Party" received high praise for its script and characters, and for the cast's performances. "Séance Time" was praised as well written and genuinely frightening, while Alison Steadman's performance being picked out for commendation by many critics. In a 2018 article for
Salon, American writer
Mary Elizabeth Williams described the series as "the best show you're not watching" and "brilliant, black-humored, taut format horror for people who enjoy the occasional potty-joke". In 2019,
Inside No. 9 was ranked 66th on
The Guardian's list of the 100 best TV shows of the 21st century. Reviewing the first episode of the 2024 final series for
The Guardian, Rachel Aroesti said, "Unlike other episodes, which are often littered with handbrake turns, this time we end up sitting tight for the big reveal. And it's completely unguessable – that violent shift in perspective executed with aplomb." The broadcast of the last ever episode, on 12 June 2024, was anticipated in several media reports.
Viewing figures Despite the generally positive reception among critics and viewers, the viewing figures for the first series were poor. The highest ratings were achieved by
The Bones of St. Nicholas with 2.7 million viewers watching within 28 days of broadcast. The ninth series of the show launched with 531,000 viewers, which comparatively was an increase from the eighth series, though slightly lower than the seventh series' opener.
Awards and nominations Inside No. 9 won the Sketch and Comedy prize at the 35th annual
Banff World Media Festival Rockie Awards. The other nominees were
Do I Have to Take Care of Everything?, ''
It's a Date, Tiny Plastic Men, Gangsta Granny and The Revolution Will Be Televised''. In response to the nomination, Shearsmith
tweeted that he was "[t]hrilled", joking that the programme was "in 'Comedy'. I knew it was one".
Inside No. 9 was also nominated for Best TV Sitcom at the 2014
Freesat Awards, which celebrate the best of
free British television. The programme lost to BBC2's
The Wrong Mans, as determined by a panel made up of television experts and commentators. In November 2014, it was announced that
Inside No. 9 had been shortlisted for the 2015
Broadcast Award for Best Original Programme. At the award ceremony in London on 4 February 2015,
Glasgow Girls was granted the award, but
Inside No. 9 was highly commended.
Inside No. 9 won the TV award at the 2015
Chortle Awards. The programme was
longlisted for the Best Comedy prize in the 2015
TV Choice Awards. The programme won the 2016 comedy
Rose d'Or, beating the Finnish
Pyjama Party and the German
Crime Scene Cleaner (
Der Tatortreiniger). At the 2014
British Comedy Awards,
Inside No. 9 was nominated in the Best New Comedy Programme and the Best Comedy Drama categories. In the former category, it lost to
Toast of London, in the latter category, it lost to
Rev. For Chater (
The Times), the comedy drama category was the strongest of the awards, but for Ben Williams (
Time Out),
Inside No. 9 should have won. Writing in
The Independent, journalist Alice Jones said she was "sorry to see the relentlessly innovative
Inside No 9 go unrewarded". == Stage productions ==