Red Notice controversies In his book ''
Red Notice: A True Story of High Finance, Murder, and One Man's Fight for Justice'',
Bill Browder, the CEO of
Hermitage Capital Management, describes how the Russian government repeatedly requested that Interpol issue a Red Notice for his arrest. Interpol refused to do so on the basis that it deemed the request was "predominantly political in nature and therefore contrary to INTERPOL's rules and regulations". With Russia unable to secure his extradition, Browder was subsequently tried and convicted by a Moscow court for tax evasion
in absentia. In January 2017, United Kingdom-based NGO
Fair Trials called on Interpol to introduce more rigorous checks. Fair Trials chief executive Jago Russell stated, "Interpol has been allowing itself to be used by oppressive regimes across the world to export the persecution of human rights defenders, journalists and political opponents". There have been concerns about conflict of interest as well as in March 2017, the UAE donated $54 million to Interpol, which roughly equalled the contributions by all other member states. Interpol's secretary-general, Jurgen Stock, stated that Interpol had introduced a task force to review requests "even more intensively". In June 2020,
Iran issued an arrest warrant for
US President Donald Trump and 35 other US political and military officials for their role in the
assassination of Qasem Soleimani and asked Interpol to issue a Red Notice. The request was rejected on the basis that this was essentially a political matter. Iran renewed the request in January 2021 after Trump left office, but it was again rejected. It was shown in 2013 that Interpol Red Notices were sometimes inaccurate and could be politically motivated.
NGOs such as
Fair Trials International have pointed to its limited internal controls to tackle political abuses. Many of its members have poor human rights records and corrupt, undemocratic governments and have been accused of abusing the Red Notice networks for political purposes. Some Red Notices are controversial and have been used to persecute opponents of regimes, for example the
former president of Ukraine, Viktor Yanukovych, whose Red Notice for
embezzlement,
misappropriation or
conversion of property was removed after it was claimed to be a political request. Interpol issued a new
refugee policy in 2015, stipulating that a Red Notice should not be issued against a refugee when it has been requested by the country from which the refugee initially fled. In November 2018,
Bahrain issued a Red Notice for footballer and
dissident Hakeem al-Araibi, who had fled Bahrain in 2014 and been granted
refugee status in Australia some years later. He was arrested on arrival in Thailand with his wife for a
honeymoon in November 2018 by Thai police on the basis of the Red Notice, despite the Red Notice being withdrawn a few days later on the basis of illegality. On 11 February, he was released after Thai prosecutors dropped the case, arriving in Australia the following day. He was granted Australian citizenship one month later, on 12 March 2019. There has been growing concern about refugees being targeted by Red Notices illegally. Recent examples before al-Araibi's case include the detention of Russian activist Petr Silaev in
Spain and Algerian human rights lawyer
Rachid Mesli in Italy. In al-Araibi's case, despite the Red Notice being withdrawn only a few days after being issued, Bahrain nonetheless issued an extradition order, and Thailand complied, leading to a trial in which al-Araibi had to defend his opposition to the extradition. ==Commission for the Control of Interpol's Files==