Agar.io was praised for the addictive nature of its simple gameplay and graphics.
PC Gamer included it on its list of the best browser games.
Engadget described the game as "a good abstraction of the fierce survival-of-the-fittest competition that you sometimes see on the microscopic level."
TouchArcade praised its simplicity, strategic element, and "personality". It was chosen by
SFGATE as App of the Week in August 2015. Criticism was mainly targeted towards its repetitiveness and the controls of the mobile version. Tom Christiansen of
Gamezebo was mixed on the game, saying that there was "nothing to hold my attention" and that it was "highly repetitive, overall".
Pocket Gamer, reviewing the mobile version, described its controls as "floaty". Game journalists also noticed that the ability to choose usernames and skins enabled players to declare their support for
geopolitical causes and figures in-game. Some even formed alliances with players supporting the same causes. Others adopted
internet memes and online platforms as their skins, as well as offensive usernames. One reviewer jokingly recounted: "I've ... seen the Earth be swallowed by Pubes, Steam absorb EA, and France split in two and flee from Mars before being eaten by Your Mom's Ass (which was, quite frankly, enormous)." An article in the journal
Games and Culture argued that the feature was the main reason for
Agar.io's success. It noted that
Agar.io provided a platform for competing ideologies in a "survival of the fittest" simulation when they would instead be shut down on social media. In an effort to make the game more commercial, Miniclip improved moderation and removed the
Swastika and
ISIS skins, a move which was described as furthering the game from its original 4chan audienceValadares himself had refused to remove the Nazi skin on
Reddit.
Agar.io was a quick success. The agar.io website (for the browser version) was ranked by
Alexa as one of the 1,000 most visited websites and the mobile versions were downloaded more than ten million times during their first week, and 113 million times as of December 2016. During 2015,
Agar.io was
Google's most searched video game. It was Google's second-most searched game in the United States in 2016. A 2015 press release by
Miniclip stated that
Agar.io was listed as the fifth top game on YouTube's list of top games. ==Similar ".io" games==