Antiquity and the Middle Ages , near the church of San Giuliano According to a historical tradition, the island was populated in antiquity by refugees who fled surrounding settlements during the devastations caused by
Hannibal's campaigns in the region. Archaeological evidence indicates a stable Roman presence: in front of the church of San Giuliano there are remains of an external retaining wall built in
opus reticulatum. In May 1139, representatives of Polvese renewed and expanded this submission, pledging loyalty to Perugia's consuls, agreeing to follow Perugia in peace and war, to pay imposed taxes, and to deliver an annual tribute of fish (specifically
tench). In 1278, the inhabitants of Polvese Island, gathered at the castle of San Feliciano, appointed Bartolo di Guidolfo as their procurator to swear loyalty to the ordinances of the Captain of the People of Perugia and his successors. Much of the island's land was then under cultivation, with vineyards worked by 88 resident families in 1279. In 1383, during the military campaigns of the condottiero
Boldrino da Panicale, Polvese Island suffered a violent sack. The inhabitants were cut off from escape and the settlement was subjected to looting and destruction by Boldrino's troops.
Early Modern period By 1410, Polvese Island was recorded as having 83 inhabitants. According to contemporary accounts by
Giovanni Antonio Campano, during the campaigns of
Braccio da Montone in the Trasimeno area, the inhabitants of Polvese Island dismantled their boats and ultimately surrendered the island to him. On 19 February 1459,
Pope Pius II was received on Polvese Island while traveling toward
Mantua. In 1632, Polvese Island served as a place of refuge for
Charles, Duke of Guise, who sought shelter there with his family after fleeing the outbreak of plague in Florence. In 1643, Polvese Island was sacked by the Florentine army commanded by Prince
Mattias de' Medici, brother of
Ferdinand II, Grand Duke of Tuscany. Following the French invasion and the proclamation of the
Roman Republic in 1798, the island was administratively incorporated into the canton of Castiglione del Lago.
Modern era In the early 19th century, the island was administratively recorded as a
frazione of Castiglione del Lago, under the government, district, delegation, and diocese of Perugia. An 1836 papal-era
gazetteer lists the island as having a population of 42 inhabitants. In the late 19th century, Polvese Island passed from the
Pianciani family to the ownership of Ferdinando Cesaroni, following land acquisitions completed between 1887 and 1888. Cesaroni used the island as a hunting estate, introducing pheasants, hares, and other game. He regularly reached the island by steamboat, reportedly the only motor vessel operating on Lake Trasimeno at the time, and organized hunting expeditions attended by guests from Florence, Rome, and Perugia.
Civil registration records from the turn of the 20th century document the presence of the Sportellini, Dolciami, and Magnani families, all listed as
coloni (
tenant farmers), as well as the Pompei family, identified as fishers. In 1904, the inhabitants of the island submitted a formal petition requesting separation from Castiglione del Lago and administrative aggregation with the municipality of Magione. The island remains administratively part of Castiglione del Lago in contemporary governance. In 1939, Biagio Biagiotti initiated the construction of various buildings and roads, alongside planting numerous olive trees all around the island. By the time of the 1971 Italian census, the resident population had fallen to just six people. In 1973, the Province of Perugia acquired Polvese Island from the real estate company NECIT, owned by Marchese Citterio, for 850 million lire (equivalent to approximately $ in today's US dollars), with the aim of preserving its historical heritage and opening it to public and cultural use. In 1974, Polvese Island was officially declared a wildlife protection oasis. == Mythology and folklore ==